Sunday, July 20, 2014

SIKKIM OBSERVER Saturday July 19-25, 2014
Blog:jigmenkazisikkim.blogspot.com
STUDENT POWER BRINGS GOVT TO ITS KNEES
GANGTOK BANDH – SCHOOLS & COLLEGES SHUT DOWN - VEHICLES SET ON FIRE – STUDENTS INJURED, HOSPITALISED – HIGHWAY CLOSED – ARMY INTERVENES
Gangtok, July 18: For the first time since Sikkim’s controversial ‘merger’ with India in early 1970s the former kingdom witnessed a bloody confrontation between the State Government and the people, this time represented largely by college students.
The bloody confrontation brought the Chamling Government on its knees when on the third day it yielded to the demands made by the student community. The agitation was partially lifted on Thursday when the student body reached an understanding with the State Government late Wednesday.
The agreement between several Cabinet ministers led by HRDD Minister RB Subba and student representatives, though not accepted by a section of the student community, binds the State Government to take action against guilty police officers, roll back fee hike, provide medical assistance to injured students and legal assistance for the probe.
The decision arrived at the meeting sought for restoration of normalcy and end to the agitation.
The agitation, aimed at protesting against hike in college fees, turned violent when the protestors were teargassed and lathicharged while holding a rally at the premises of Sikkim Government College at Tadong.
Several students were injured and hospitalized, two vehicles were torched and at least 30 vehicles were damaged while mediapersons were assaulted and a high-ranking police officer was roughed up during the three-day-long confrontation.
Though political parties condemned police brutality against peaceful protestors the agitation was largely a students vs police affair.
Former minister and Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (SKM) President PS Golay rejected the formation of the State Government’s one-man committee to probe into what he described as “inhuman” acts of the Sikkim Police against agitating students. He demanded that  Home Minister  Pawan Chamling  and HRDD Minister RB Subba  apologize to the student community.
The BJP Sikkim unit President Palden Wangchuk condemned the lathicharge. He said “in a democracy people have a right to voice their grievances.” The BJP also condemned “the unnecessary and drastic hike in the fees structure” of colleges in the State.
Even as schools and colleges were closed down for a week due to the agitation, the Principal Secretary of Human Resource Development Department Thomas Chandy appealed to the student community to resume their classes as the fee hike decision has been rolled back.
The One-Man Committee, to be headed by C.T.Wangdi, Secretary, Land Revenue and Disaster Management Department, is expected to submit his report within 15 days.
As the days progressed muster roll and ad-hoc employees, taxi drivers and a section of the public also joined in the movement. The capital’s shops were shut for two days – Wednesday and Thursday – and the national highway was closed down for sometime.
To contain the situation the Army was brought in on Wednesday. It held a flag-march in Tadong in full battle gear.
Nine SKM legislators sat on hunger strike outside the main Secretariate on Wednesday protesting against police atrocities against the student community. This put more pressure on the authorities to meet the demands of the student community. (also see page 4)
South district students threaten to renew strike if demands not met
Namchi, July 18: The Students of Namchi Government College and student representatives of South District have condemned the police action against the students on 14th and 15th July at Gangtok and demanded strict and immediate action from the state government.
   They said that the issue had not been settled yet. Students will wait for 15 days for the investigation of the incident and if they are denied justice they will continue their agitation and this time students of all four districts will join in the agitation.
South district students have demanded strict action against SP East and PI Sadar Thana for the lathi-charge against the students when they were only fighting for their rights, Talk Sikkim website reported.
They also demanded there should be no bias in the investigation of the incident and that all the police and IRB personnel involved in the incident should be punished accordingly.
Speaking about the incident the students expressed dissatisfaction about the way the HRD Department handled the issue. They said that if the department had put the notice about the price hike earlier in the college fee, a solution would have been found and no such incident would have taken place which ended with so many injured students.
The short notice given by the department about hike in college fee had made students worried as maximum students were not in a position to afford to pay the extra amount.
Subsequently, the non-cooperation from the department had forced them to block the National Highway. “But instead of listening to our demands, we were lathi-charged by the police,” they said, the report said.
Chief Minister Pawan Chamling called on Union Home Minister Rajnath Singh in New Delhi this week and apprised him on various issues pertaining to Sikkim, including Assembly seat reservation for Limbus and Tamangs and income tax exemption for Sikkim’s left-out persons.
Tibetan Parliamentary delegation meets Indian MPs on Tibet
Dharamshala, July 18: A Tibetan parliamentary delegation has met newly-elected members of Indian Parliament from different political parties in New Delhi and the latter expressed their continued support for the Tibetan people.
The Tibetan parliament delegation comprise of Geshe Monlam Tharchin, Dolma Tsering, Acharya Yeshi Phuntsok, Choekyong Wangchuk and Lobsang Yeshi.
The delegation is scheduled meet many members of India’s lower house of Parliament, Lok Sabha, to convey their greetings and make efforts to reinvigorate the All Party Indian Parliamentary Forum for Tibet.
The delegation met Dr. Prasanna Kumar Patasani, a member of Parliament from India’s Biju Janata Dal party.  Dr Patasani, who has participated in many Tibet-related conferences, said he understands the sufferings of Tibetans under China’s repressive rule and expressed his continued support for the Tibetan cause.
 He said he would rally his parliamentary colleagues to join the All Party Indian Parliamentary Forum for Tibet. He also expressed his support to lobby the parliamentary foreign affairs committee to seek Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s support on the issue of Tibet. He said he would make efforts to participate in the upcoming World Parliamentarians Convention on Tibet.
  Some of key Indian Parliamentarians that the Tibetan delegation met  include Ajit Singh, former minister and chief of Rashtriya Lok Dal, who is the founding member of International Tibet Support, Jayant Chaudhary, P D Rai of Sikkim Democratic Front, Shashi Tharoor of Indian National Congress and Sharad Yadav of Janata Dal United. They pledged to continue their support for the issue of Tibet, join themselves in the All Party Indian Parliamentary Forum for Tibet and encourage party colleagues to do so.
Editorial
KARMAPA CONTROVERSY
India Must Tread Carefully
If Nepal succumbs to Chinese pressure Shamar Rinpoche’s funeral will not take place in the former Hindu Kingdom. This will surely prove China’s influence in the sensitive border region in the Himalayan frontier. It is one thing to squabble over who really is the 17th Karmapa and quite another thing to be influenced by big powers which are using religion to spread its wings. The Buddhist cultural landscape from Ladakh in Jammu and Kashmir in the west to Arunachal Pradesh in the east along the porous Himalayan belt – a natural wall between Asia’s two giants– is vital for both China and India’s security. Even before Shamar Rinpoche’s funeral rites are over Sikkim has demanded the early return of the 17th Karmapa Ugyen Thinley Dorje to Rumtek. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government at the Centre needs to be widely aware of the political ramifications of the Karmapa controversy in this sensitive region. He must, therefore, be carefully briefed and properly guided by competent authorities to avoid another Himalayan blunder.
Did Shamar Rinpoche’s funeral plans fall foul of Himalayan power politics?
Kathmandu, July 18: The government of Nepal has revoked its decision to allow the last rituals of a prominent Buddhist leader who passed away in Germany last month due to heart attack, reported The New York Times.
The Nepalese Embassy in New Delhi had earlier issued a “no objection letter” for the body of Shamar Rinpoche to be taken to Nepal for the last rituals but reversed the decision after Nepal’s Ministry of Home Affairs and Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued directives to revoke the permission.
As per the wishes of the late Shamar Rinpoche his body was scheduled to be brought to Nepal for cremation at his own monastery, the Shar Minub in Kathmandu, on Monday.
   The body of Shamar Rinpoche was kept at the Karmapa Buddhist Institute in New Delhi till July 1st, and then at Diwakar Institute in Kalimpong. "Due to some unanticipated circumstances, we have had to postpone the departure of Shamar Rinpoche’s kudung from Kalimpong on July 13, 2014. We regret the inconvenience that this may have caused on your travel plans. We will be providing the updates once the date has been confirmed," said a statement on the official website of Shamar Rinpoche.
   Shamar Rinpoche, 62, who held the title Sharmapa, had died of a heart attack in Germany in June. His supporters wanted to fulfil his wishes and transport his body first to Kalimpong, in India’s north-east, and then to Nepal for a funeral service at an institute he had established.
But his supporters around the world fear their teacher may have fallen foul of power politics playing out in the Himalayas. Having initially granted the go-ahead for his body to be taken to Nepal, the authorities in Kathmandu have now withdrawn permission. It has been reported they did so under pressure from neighbouring China, which does not want to encourage Tibetan Buddhism in Nepal, The Independent reported.
A spokesman for Nepal’s home ministry, Laxmi Prasad Dhakal, confirmed permission had been given and then subsequently withdrawn.
Dhakal said officials at the Nepalese Embassy in Delhi had granted permission when it was believed the Sharmapa held a Nepalese passport. He said it was then discovered he held a Bhutanese passport and officials said permission could not be given as there was no legal provision for allowing foreigners to travel to Nepal for a funeral.
Asked whether Nepal had acted under pressure from China, he said: “No, no, no. That’s not true – 200 per cent not true.”
The Sharmapa held a senior position within the Karma Kagyu school of Tibetan Buddhism, yet he was not without controversy. In 1992, he broke from the opinion of many other senior teachers and declined to recognise the person identified as the 17 Karmapa, who heads the Karma Kagyu school.
Indeed, he instead identified his own candidate. Today, the Karma Kagyu school remains split over who is its true head. The Chinese government recognises the Karmapa that the Sharmapa refused to recognise.
Shamar Rinpoche Mipham Chokyi Lodro was born in Derge, Tibet. At the age of four he was recognized by the 16th Karmapa, Rangjung Rigpei Dorje as the 14th Shamarpa.
The 14th Shamar Rimpoche wass one of the three main disciples of the previous Karmapa. After the death of the 16th Karmapa, Shamarpa recognized Thaye Dorje as the 17th Karmapa in 1994. However, Tai Situpa Rinpoche chose another boy, Ogyen Trinley Dorje as the 17th Karmapa who was approved by the Tibetan leader His Holiness the Dalai Lama.
Deal with students in a humane manner: BJP


Gangtok, July 18: The Sikkim State Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has condemned the incidence of lathicharge and bursting of tear gas shells on innocent students  here this week.
Party chief Palden Wangchuk said it was the collective administrative failure of the State Government to handle the situation which led to law and order problem.
“The party condemns violence of any sort,” the BJP release said.
It said the administration should have dealt the issues raised by the students in a “humane and compassionate manner”.





Sunday, June 29, 2014

SIKKIM OBSERVER Saturday June 28 – July 4, 2014
Blog:jigmenkazisikkim.blogspot.com
Fiery Assembly session: Opp keeps govt on its toes
SKM LEGISLATORS WALKOUT IN PROTEST AGAINST ‘ANTI-NATIONAL’ TAG
Gangtok, June 27: For the first time in years the budget session of the Assembly this time has been a fiery one. Led by Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (SKM) President PS Golay, the treasury bench was kept on its toes with members of the Opposition comprising 10 MLAs refusing to budge and cornered the government on many issues ranging from Article 371F, Assembly seat reservation for Tamang and Limbu communities, water shortage and poor maintenance of roads in the State.
On Tuesday, the Sangha MLA Sonam Kaloen Lama charged the government of its neglect in not mentioning the long-pending demand for restoration of Assembly seats of Sikkimese Nepalese in the Governor’s address.
There was heated exchange of words when Chief Minister Pawan Chamling alleged that any reference to the historic Tripartite Agreement of May 8, 1973 was ‘anti-national’.
The Chief Minister’s refusal to acknowledge a letter communicated to the Union Government by his own Chief Secretary ND Chingapa in 2006 that suggested seat reservation issue for Limbu- Tamangs  be kept on hold did not go down well with the Opposition.
The government’s failure to grant income tax exemption to the State’s old settlers figured in the Assembly debate. Chamling closed the lid on this explosive issue by stating that the matter was with the Supreme Court.
Another touchy issue raised in the Assembly by the Opposition was the government’s move to do away with the categorisation of a section of Nepalese listed as Most Backward Classes (MBC) and to revert them back to their former OBC status.
The drama in the Assembly climaxed when the entire Opposition legislators led by Golay staged a walkout from the Assembly today in protest against the move to brand Opposition legislators as ‘anti-national’ when they raised issues regarding Article 371F.
“When we raised the issue of Article 371F we were termed anti-national and we walked out of the House in protest. When we talk about Article 371F we were accused of going against the Constitution,” Golay said at a hurriedly convened press conference after the walkout.
Golay also alleged that the Speaker KN Rai acted in a discriminatory manner and failed to observe the rules of the House. The walkout was also in protest against the Speaker’s decision to expunge Golay’s statement on numerous issues during Zero Hour from proceedings of the House.
On Monday, the Chief Minister presented the annual budget of Rs 6666.71 crore of which the plan outlay is fixed at Rs 3497.03 and non-plan at Rs. 3169.68.
Shamar Rinpoche: cremation in Kathmandu on July 31
Kudung to remain in Kalimpong for a fortnight from July 1
Gangtok, June 27: The funeral of Shamar Rinpoche, who passed away in Germany on June 11, will be held in Kathmandu on July 31, coinciding with the auspicious day when Lord Buddha first turned the Wheel of Dharma.
One of the most prominent spiritual figures of Tibetan Buddhism and one of the most influential personalities of Karma Kagyu tradition of Tibetan Buddhism died of cardiac arrest at the meditation center of his Bodhi Path organization in Renchen-Ulm, sources said. He was only 61.
   Shamar Rinpoche Mipham Chokyi Lodro was born in Derge, Kham, in eastern Tibet. At the age of four he was recognized by the 16th Karmapa, Rangjung Rigpei Dorje,  as the 14th Shamarpa.
The 14th Shamar Rinpoche is one of the three main disciples of the previous Karmapa. After the death of the 16th Karmapa, Shamarpa recognized Thaye Dorje as the 17th Karmapa in 1994. However, Tai Situpa Rinpoche chose another boy, Ogyen Trinley Dorje, as the 17th Karmapa who was also approved by the Tibetan leader His Holiness the Dalai Lama.
In a statement after his meeting with the Dalai Lama on August 13, 2010, Shamar Rinpoche said, “I met His Holiness the Dalai Lama iin Dharamsala at His Holiness’ residence. We had a discussion for approximately one and a half hours and had a very important and detailed exchange of views regarding the ongoing Karmapa controversy and its possible solution. Although this matter is not easily resolved, since it is connected to the politics of China and India as well, with His Holiness Dalai Lama’s blessing and support I am confident that there will be an amicable solution, which will be beneficial for the Karma Kagyü lineage, as well as for Tibetan Buddhism in general.”          
Several thousand Buddhists from all over the world met at Renchen village to pay their last respects to Shamar Rinpoche. His Holiness the 17th Karmapa Thaye Dorje led the impressive farewell ceremony for his teacher. He accompanied Shamar Rinpoche on his last journey to New Delhi, where his mortal remains is being kept.
Shamar Rinpoche himself did not fear death. In one of his last teachings he said: "You don't need to be afraid of death if you know how to practice [meditation] in death."
After his death, letters of condolence were received from many high masters of Tibetan Buddhism as well as the Royal Family of the Kingdom of Bhutan. "I have known Rinpoche for many years and my family and I will always remember Shamar Rinpoche as a close and dear friend," His Majesty Druk Gyalpo Jigme Singye Wangchuck, the 4th King of Bhutan, wrote.
  With its more than 180 meditation and study centers, the Karma Kagyu is the most widespread Buddhist school in Germany. It is worldwide represented by more than 900 monasteries as well as meditation centers under the guidance of Karmapa Thaye Dorje.
Since the Kudung of Sharmar Rinpoche arrived at the Karmapa International Buddhist Institute (KIBI) from Germany, His Holiness Karmapa Thaye Dorje along with the sangha have been performing daily prayers.
The Kudung of Shamar Rinpoche, accompanied by His Holiness Karmapa Thaye Dorje, will be leaving for Kalimpong on the July 1. Devotees of the Late Rinpoche from Bhutan, Sikkim and Darjeeling will pay their respects to the departed soul while the Kudung remains for a fortnight at  Kalimpong’s Shri Diwakar Vihara Buddhist Research and Educational Institute that Rinpoche had established.
Attempts were made to bring the Kudung to Rumtek monastery in Sikkim but the authorities refused to give permission citing law and order problem.
On July 14, His Holiness Karmapa Thaye Dorje will be accompanying Kudung of Rinpoche on the final journey to Shar Minub Monastery in Kathmandu, the main seat of Shamar Rinpoche, which will be the final resting place for his Kudung. The cremation will take place on July 31, which coincides with the first turning of the dharma wheel by Buddha Shakyamuni.
During Sharmar Rinpoche’s lifetime, it was his wish to build a Kudung stupa in the land of his own seat. Thus, a stupa will be constructed to contain the remains of the 14th Shamarpa.
HIMALAYAN Buddhism
Shamar Rinpoche fled Tibet with 16th Karmapa and settled in Sikkim
14th Shamarpa Mipham Chökyi Lodrö (1952 – 2014)
Kunzig Shamar Rinpoche died of a cardiac arrest on June 11th, 2014 in Renchen-Ulm, Germany, at the age of 62. Many Buddhists worldwide are deeply stricken by his death. With heartfelt thankfulness and great respect we bid farewell to our lineage holder.
The 14th Shamarpa Mipham Chokyi Lodro was one of the highest Lamas of Tibetan Buddhism. As lineage holder of the Karma Kagyu tradition, against much political resistance, he enthroned Trinley Thaye Dorje as the 17th Karmapa in accordance to the tradition.
Mipham Chökyi Lodrö was born in Derge (East Tibet) in 1952. At four years of age he was recognized as the 14th incarnation of the Shamar Tulkus by his uncle, the 16th Karmapa.
Together with the 16th Karmapa he fled the Chinese occupied Tibet in 1959, leaving his Tibetan seat Yangpachen behind, finally reaching Sikkim. At Rumtek monastery, he received a traditional training and the complete transmission of the Karma Kagyu School. Subsequently the Karmapa, the head of the tradition, appointed him as the next lineage holder.
Thus the 16th Karmapa followed the history of the Karma Kagyu tradition. Many Shamarpas before had been the closest students of the respective Karmapas as well as the teacher of the succeeding one. Next to the Karmapa’s, the tradition of the Shamarpas is the second oldest lineage of Buddhist masters leaving clues prior to their death predicting their next reincarnation in order to be able to continue the activity of their predecessors as soon as possible. The lineage of the Shamar Tulkus goes back to the 13th century.
     The 14th Shamar Rinpoche and the 16th Gyalwa Karmapa.
In 1967, the 16th Karmapa confirmed Kunzig Shamarpa in an official document as the second highest Lama of the Karma Kagyu school, thereby appointing him with the responsibility of finding and enthroning the next lineage holder. Karmapa Rangjung Rigpe Dorje died in 1981. To share the responsibility of administrating Rumtek, Karmapa’s seat in exile, and other affairs of the Karma Kagyu tradition, a council of young high-ranking Lamas more or less of the same age had formed. Along with Shamar Rinpoche, it consisted of Situ Rinpoche, Jamgon Kongtrul Rinpoche and Gyaltsab Rinpoche.
Soon disagreements arose among the four. Shamar Rinpoche had clues about the reincarnation of the 16th Karmapa. Because of the Chinese occupation it was difficult to get in touch with his family in Central Tibet. Meanwhile Situ Rinpoche sought for cooperation with the Chinese authorities to abet a limited revival of Buddhism and the reconstruction of destroyed monasteries in Tibet. The situation got increasingly critical when in spring of 1992 Jamgon Kongtrul Rinpoche, who had repeatedly been mediating between the two parties, died in a car accident.
  Situ Rinpoche named a nomad boy from East Tibet as the new Karmapa candidate and enthroned him at the Karmapas’ main seat at Tsurphu monastery, giving him the name Urgyen Trinley Dorje. Beforehand, he had obtained the consent of the Chinese government as well as the Dalai Lama, the political leader of Tibetans in exile.
While Situ Rinpoche’s Karmapa candidate Urgyen Trinley Dorje was not allowed to travel and the Communist Party was trying to put him up for political purposes, Shamarpa prepared the flight of his Karmapa Thaye Dorje from Tibet. It was very important for him, that the future Karmapa should be able to grow up and work in freedom.
In accordance with the tradition of the Karma Kagyu lineage, Shamar Rinpoche, after the Karmapa the highest-ranking lineage holder, enthrones Thaye Dorje as the 17th Gyalwa Karmapa.
Aided by Western Buddhists, Karmapa Thaye Dorje reached India. At the beginning of 1994, he was officially enthroned according to the tradition of the Karma Kagyu lineage by the Shamarpa. In the following years, the relationship between Shamarpa and the Tibet Government in Exile was not always easy. Legal disputes about Karmapa’s seat in exile at Rumtek and the relics stored there dragged out. In various talks with the Dalai Lama, Kunzig Shamar Rinpoche tried to find a mutual agreement for the situation.
Shamar Rinpoche was a highly respected teacher of Buddhists in the East and the West. He gave numerous teachings and empowerments in Diamondway Buddhist Centers and at the Europe Center, the international meeting point of Diamondway Buddhism in Immenstadt. To meet the needs of his Western students especially following his curriculum, in the 1990s Shamarpa founded the Bodhi Path centers which today are represented in 20 countries throughout Europe, America and Asia.
In “Creating a Transparent Democracy” he drafted a model for a political system and a society inspired by Buddhist principles. The preface was written by the South African bishop and Nobel Peace laureate Desmond Tutu. He also wrote an extensive biography of the 10th Karmapa Choying Dorje (1604-1674) who lived in difficult political times in Tibet. Kunzig Shamar Rinpoche also founded an organization for the protection of animals called “Infinite Compassion Foundation” that especially worked for a humane treatment of productive livestock.
A few days before his death Shamar Rinpoche guided a meditation course in Renchen-Ulm. One of his last teachings was: “You don’t have to be afraid of death if you know how to practice in death.” (Bodi Path Renchen-Ulm Karmapa in Deutschland (German) Shamarpa.org)
Editorial
‘SIKKIM SUBJECT’ ISSUE
Right Move, Wrong Time
The move that could have got the overwhelming support of bonafide Sikkimese is now met with derision and suspicion. The Chamling Government’s decision to accord top priority to ‘Sikkim Subjects’, citizens of the former Kingdom of Sikkim, in matters pertaining to employment, incentives, facilities etc. in Sikkim is widely perceived to be a move to punish those who sided with the Opposition Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (SKM) and voted against the ruling Sikkim Democratic Front (SDF) in the recent Assembly and Lok Sabha polls rather than a genuine effort to protect the rights and interests of bonafide Sikkimese who basically hail from the three ethnic communities – Lepchas, Bhutias and Nepalese of Sikkimese origin. And yet this decision – irrespective of whatever the motive and undue delay in its implementation – if pursued to its logical conclusion will go a long way in giving justice to the Sikkimese people who have for long hoped and prayed that the Chamling Government and in particular the Chief Minister, Pawan Chamling, himself will come to their senses and honour the commitment made to the Sikkimese people before the 1994 Assembly polls. It is most unfortunate that the present government which  has been in power for over two decades since December 1994 is now realizing the present predicament faced by the locals and taking precautionary measures to set things right.
If he is serious Chamling ought to follow Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s example of setting an ideal example and starting the clearing up process right from the top. Firstly, the present legislators, including the two MPs, must disclose their Sikkim Subject Certificate in original for public scrutiny. The alleged 35,000 fake Sikkim Subject Certificates held by a section of the State’s residents must be scrapped with immediate effect. Secondly, Article 371F, which is based on the historic May 8, 1973 Tripartite Agreement, ensures that Assembly seats be reserved for bonafide Sikkimese possessing genuine Sikkim Subject Certificate. Therefore, the Chamling Government must revive its demand for reservation of Assembly seats for Sikkimese Nepalese. The 12 reserved seats in the Assembly should also be restored to bonafide Sikkimese Bhutia-Lepchas. The Modi Government, too, must honour the terms of Sikkim’s merger and restore the traditional political rights of the Sikkimese people at the earliest.

Narendra Modi’s Bhutan visit will expand India’s influence in Asia

By CLAUDE ARPI

     School children greeting Prime Minister Narendra Modi in Bhutan recently.
On Sunday afternoon, Prime Minister Narendra Modi landed at Thimphu. A touching ceremonial welcome by Bhutanese school children awaited him. It was Modi’s first visit abroad.
Fifty six years ago Jawaharlal Nehru, the first Prime Minister of independent India, visited Bhutan too. But it was another era.
In October 1958, in a letter to the Chief Ministers, Nehru recalls: “After I left Gangtok, I was almost entirely cut off from communications till my return to Gangtok two and a half weeks later. I received an occasional message by wireless from Delhi. …There were no newspapers at all and I had a sensation of being in another world.”
At that time, it was no question of landing anywhere in Bhutan. The PM, Indira Gandhi and their entourage had to undertake a long trek via the Chumbi Valley in Tibet. It was the customary and easiest road to reach the Kingdom of the Dragon. India had just built a road till Nathu-la, the border between Sikkim and Tibet.
Nehru remarked: “On the Tibetan side, this road will be a much simpler proposition than the one that we have built on our side. Through road traffic would make a great difference to trade as well as to travellers. There is still a considerable inflow of goods from India to Tibet although this has gone down during the last year or two.”
Why should the trade have gone down? Simply because the Chinese had established themselves on the Tibetan plateau and had decided to drastically reduce the trade exchanges between India and Tibet.
At that time, India still had a Consulate General in Lhasa and 3 Trade Agencies in Gyantse, Yatung and Gartok (Western Tibet).
Nehru, who spent 2 nights in Yatung’s Trade Agency, recalled: “Yatung was a small spread out town. The main market road was full of Indian shops. There were, I believe, over ninety such shops, many of them having started business in the course of the last three years, when this trade was highly profitable. Conditions were more difficult now and so a number of these Indian shops were closing up. The Chinese authorities had put up a number of new buildings-schools, hospital, community centre and residential houses for themselves. Our own Trade Agent’s house had its own little hospital and buildings for the staff.”
Unfortunately, the relations with the Himalayan States, which have for centuries been so important to India, deteriorated a few months later, with the uprising in Lhasa in March 1959 and the consequent flight of the Dalai Lama to India. Thereafter, the Chinese tightened their grip on the Tibetan plateau; this was a tragedy for India and its security.
By paying his first visit to Bhutan, Narendra Modi has probably decided to change the tide.
The Times of India reported that Modi has “stepped up a charm offensive with neighbours to try to check China’s influence in the region.”
Before leaving, the PMO had released a statement putting the visit in perspective: “Bound by common interests and shared prosperity, India and Bhutan enjoy a unique and special relationship, which has been forged by ties of geography, history and culture. Therefore, Bhutan as the destination for my first visit abroad as Prime Minister is a natural choice. Relations with Bhutan will be a key foreign policy priority of my Government.”
Modi’s first visit abroad comes ahead of the 22nd round of bilateral talks between Bhutan and China which are expected to take place in July or August. Since 1986, these talks are officially aimed at resolving the long-pending border dispute between Bhutan and China.
For some time now, Thimphu has been tempted to have a more official relationship with Beijing. It is probably why Modi was accompanied by Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj, National Security Advisor (NSA) Ajit Doval and Foreign Secretary Sujatha Singh.
On August 9 last year, the then NSA Shivshankar Menon visited Bhutan. There was more in his visit than a routine exchange on the 11th Bhutanese Plan.
It was clear that the NSA’s main purpose was to see with the Bhutanese Government how to handle the border talks with China.
The 21st round of boundary talks between Bhutan’s Foreign Minister Rinzim Dorje and the Chinese vice-Minister in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs were to be held two weeks later.
The New Indian Express then mentioned “a shift in emphasis from the disputed north-western, close to Siliguri corridor, to the central parts of Bhutan,” this made Delhi nervous.
The Sino-Bhutanese border talks have always had serious strategic implications for India’s security.
A particular Chinese claim worries India. It is the Doklam plateau, adjacent to the hyper-strategic Chumbi valley, crossed by Nehru 56 years ago. This is the real nightmare for India.
At the time of Menon’s visit, Liu Zengyi, a research fellow at Shanghai Institutes for International Studies admitted in The Global Times that for India, China’s advances in the Doklam area was a strategic threat to the Siliguri corridor: “As a country located between China and India, Bhutan serves as a buffer and is of critical strategic importance to the Siliguri corridor, a narrow stretch of land (known as chicken’s neck) that connects India’s north-eastern States to the rest of India. …The corridor is considered a vulnerable bottleneck for India’s national security. New Delhi worries that China will send troops to the corridor if a China-Indian military clash breaks out.”
It is indeed a vital issue for New Delhi. Incidentally, the present Bhutanese PM Tshering Tobgay’s constituency is adjacent to the territory claimed by China.
 Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru on his visit to Bhutan in 1958.
Interestingly, when Nehru crossed the Chumbi valley in 1958, there was no discrepancy between the Chinese and Bhutanese maps (except for eastern Bhutan where Beijing did not recognise the McMahon Line) and no claim on Doklam.
Since then, the PLA has intruded in several areas and has built important infrastructure, such as the road from Yatung to Phari in the Chumbi Valley. The Doklam area overlooks this highway. The Chinese engineers have also built traversal roads and set up a communication network within the disputed area. By grabbing the Doklam Plateau, Beijing considerably enlarged the Chumbi valley and its access to Sikkim and Siliguri.
How to dislodge the Chinese will not be an easy task. At the same time, the cordial people-to-people relations between India and Bhutan had to be reaffirmed. A Bhutanese well—known nature photographer wrote in his blog: “In recent times, our relationship has digressed from being trustworthy buddies to that of being an estranged couple – slowly drifting apart with the danger of finally ending in divorce. This would be so unfortunate. …I hope that somewhere tucked away in a small corner of his luggage, Mister Modi brings with him a brand new and re-tinkered foreign policy initiative towards Bhutan that is progressive and based on trust and good intention.”
Let’s hope that Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s first visit would have also achieved this. (niticentral)
Centre to invest Rs 5,000 crore to set up 8,000 telecom towers in northeast
New Delhi, June 27: The Union Government will invest Rs 5,000 crore to set up over 8,000 telecom towers in northeastern region.
Ravi Shankar Prasad, Minister of Communications and Information Technology, said improving telecom connectivity in the north east is one of the top priorities of the government.
Telecom Commission had cleared the proposal a few days ago.
The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India had last year recommended an investment plan to improve services in north east India, PTI reported.
The TRAI recommended a 2 percent discount on annual license fees for telecom operators that cover at least 80 percent of habitations with a population of 250 and subsidies for installation of solar power units at telecom towers.
The Indian regulator also recommended investments to provide seamless connectivity across national highways in the north east region covering Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland, Sikkim and Tripura.
State-run companies BSNL and Power Grid Corporation of India recently signed an agreement to improve telecom connectivity in the region.
The Telecom Commission has approved the long-pending project of installing mobile towers in nine Naxal-hit states, for which BSNL had submitted an estimate of Rs 3,241 crore, which was higher than Rs 3,046 crore approved by the Cabinet.
The project will be placed before the Cabinet for final approval.
 Road projects along China border to get fast-track approval
New Delhi, June 27: After giving two quick green clearances to defence projects, the environment ministry has now decided to fast-track road projects along India-China border. These road projects within 100 kilometres of the Line of Actual Control (LAC) are crucial for troop movements and other related developments for security point of view.
A decision on environmental and forest clearances on building defence infrastructure in areas in the 100 km-range from the LAC can be taken by the state governments concerned, Union Environment Minister Prakash Javadekar said. "Construction of roads within 100 kilometres of Line of Actual Control will be given fast-track approval", said the environment minister Prakash Javadekar. A policy in this regard will be formulated very soon, he told reporters. The 4,056-km-long LAC with China touches four states — J&K, Uttarakhand, Himachal Pradesh and Sikkim, The Times of India reported.
Interestingly, it is the second such decision keeping China in mind.
The ministry has earlier given its go ahead to set up a radar station at Narcondam in Andaman & Nicobar Islands.
The project was pending for long despite repeated requests from the defence establishment which wanted to install the radar at the strategic location in view of suspected Chinese presence and "listening post" on nearby Coco Island.
China-made aircraft starts commercial flights in Nepal
Kathmandu, June 27: Nepal's first ever China-made aircraft, a 58-seater Modern Ark 60 (MA60), started commercial operations on Wednesday, Nepali officials said.
The MA60 was handed over to the Nepal Airlines Corporation by the Chinese government in April, Xinhua reported.
"The plane made its first successful commercial operation from Kathmandu's airport to Biratnagar," Ram Hari Sharma, spokesperson for the Nepali airline said.
 Airline executives said the plane was operated by two Chinese pilots from China's Xi'an Aircraft Industrial Corporation, the producer of the aircraft.
Lhasa-Shigatse rail link by Sept
Lhasa, June 27: When it opened eight years ago, the railway from Golmud to Lhasa was one of the most ambitious rail ventures ever attempted. At a cost of $4 billion, tracks were built across 550km (340 miles) of permafrost, reaching an altitude of 5,000 metres (16,400 feet)—the highest railway in the world. This September, an extension of the line will open from Lhasa to Shigatse, the first part of a further plan to knit Tibet into the rest of China.
The line to Shigatse stretches 250km southwest of Lhasa and will reduce the five-hour road journey to two hours by rail. As well as allowing easier access for tourists to Tibet’s second city, it will make an area rich in natural resources more accessible. (The Chinese name for Tibet, Xizang, translates as “Western treasurehouse”.) In the autumn the construction is due to start on another extension, running 400km from Lhasa to Nyingtri, a county with large hydropower potential.
By 2020 the aim is to complete several other major rail routes connecting Tibet with its neighbouring provinces of Xinjiang, Sichuan and Yunnan (see map). One of them, a 1,900km railway from Lhasa to Chengdu, will cost more than $20 billion.
Two more railways from Shigatse to the Nepalese and Indian borders, at Nyalam and Dromo, are also planned, to the alarm of the Indian government, which last week announced plans to fortify 54 new border posts in Arunachal Pradesh, a north-eastern state that China invaded in 1962.
LITERARY
 ‘Anglo-Indians are in search of an identity
Kevin Martin’s debut work, Double Cream, Memsahib?, a novel-in-verse, was launched in Chennai recently
When Kevin Martin speaks, there are no hurried sentences rushing into each other. He is calm and relaxed, and weighs each question carefully before answering it. “My mind is a strange place. It’s very volatile, but I use it to my advantage while writing,” says the Anglo-Indian author from Sydney.
Kevin was born and raised in Podanur, Tamil Nadu. The eldest of four children, he says he inherited the writing bug from his mother who was a teacher. In Chennai to launch his début fiction novel-in-verse Double Cream, Memsahib? Kevin says that he is highly influenced by Vikram Seth (whose Golden Gate is also a novel in verse). “I admire the man and his style of writing. I began writing with his work as the standard to reach,” he says with a smile.
The story revolves around Darius Rembrandt, a young, shy, poetry-writing Anglo-Indian boy who witnesses two English soldiers raping a woman on the banks of the Hooghly on the day India is granted independence. What follows is a roller-coaster ride of emotions: horror and wonderment vie with each other as the narrative follows the characters whose lives get intertwined by fate. “We Anglo-Indians might be happy with our lives, but we are always in search of an identity. My book reflects that search,” says Kevin.
“Fate is something I strongly believe in even in real life,” he adds. “That’s what has brought me here. Like Frederick Forsyth when he was trying to find a publisher for Day of the Jackal, I too had a file full of rejection letters. You know, the type which lavishly compliments your work and follows it up with a ‘but’,” he says.
Fate pointed Kevin to a Morrissey concert in Brisbane; the concert in Sydney had sold out. “I didn’t want to miss it as he’s my favourite singer. While I was in Brisbane, I stayed at my aunt’s house. She handed me some copies of Anglos In The Wind (AITW) and also told me about Anglo Ink,” says Kevin.
“I must confess that I hadn’t heard of AITW till then,” says Kevin, giving its editor, Harry MacLure, an apologetic look.
When Harry, who is also the publisher of Anglo Ink, wrote back to Kevin, the latter kept looking for a ‘but’ in the mail.
“Harry had also given the manuscript to someone else, and they too gave the go ahead. For so long, I had only heard ‘No’ to my book. All of a sudden, there were two people saying yes!” he says, recalling the excitement and exhilaration that came with his book being accepted.
But why verse? “I began writing in prose, but it fell flat. I then tried blank verse, but it didn’t reflect our community — we are anything but blank. The richness and vibrancy of sonnets capture the vibe of Anglo-Indians, and despite my apprehensions, I stuck with it and I’m quite happy with the result,” says Kevin. With a grin, he adds, “When I started off, the going was quite slow: I wrote at the rate of 85 words a day. Stephen King recommends 1,000 words a day.”
To young writers, Kevin says, “Remember that writing is a lonely, lonely task. You will be confronted by the tyranny of the blank page: it masters you until you fill it with your words and master it.”
The book was released by S. Muthiah, editor of Madras Musings and received by author, playwright and poet Shreekumar Varma. Theatre personality N.S. Yamuna and Superintendent of Customs, Chennai, Richard O’Connor read excerpts from the novel. The launch was co-hosted by Madras Book Club at Vivanta By Taj Connemara.
 (Double Cream, Memsahib? (Rs. 350) is available online at www.angloink.com. - The Hindu. Note from Sikkim Observer Editor: Kevin Martin and I not only did our TTC (Darjeeling) from the same institution but also taught at Mt. Hermon School, Darjeeling, and played for the school’s cricket team.)
DISTINCT IDENTITY
Within the Union
Gradual dilution of Sikkim’s distinct identity
May  8th 1973: Historic day for Sikkim
By Jigme N Kazi
In the first picture I’m with three historic personalities of Sikkim politics: Kazi Lhendup Dorji Khangsarpa (centre), the first Chief Minister of Sikkim (1974-1979), Krishna Chandra Pradhan (on Kazi’s right), and Bhim Bahadur Gurung (on Kazi’s left). The three were signatories to the historic May 8, 1973 Tripartite Agreement. This pact was signed between the Government of India, Chogyal of Sikkim and leaders of three major political parties in Sikkim. Former Gangtok MLA and Mayor Balchand Sarda is on the extreme left in the picture.
While LD Kazi represented the Sikkim National Congress in the historic Agreement, KC Pradhan and BB Gurung belonged to the Sikkim Janata Congress. The Late Netuk Tsering represented the Sikkim National Party.
The Agreement while curtailing the Chogyal’s power gave more political rights to the majority Sikkimese Nepalese. It also brought Sikkim closer to India.
The May 8, 1973 Agreement gradually paved way for Sikkim’s absorption into the Indian Union in April-May 1975. Article 371F of the Constitution of India, which provides special status to Sikkim, is based on the May 8th Agreement. 
Viewed from the historical perspective, the 1890 Convention signed between Great Britain and China and the Indo-Sikkim Treaty of 1950 paved way for the May 8th 1973 Tripartite Agreement. Under the 1890 Convention Sikkim was made a British Protectorate. The Protectorate status continued after India’s Independence under the 1950 Treaty.
After the Indian takeover of Sikkim in 1975 Article 371F of the Constitution defined Sikkim’s status within the Indian Union.
The dilution of Sikkim’s special place within India has been a source of constant political tension in the former kingdom after the ‘merger’ in 1975. If the tension continues it may eventually lead to political uncertainty in this strategic and sensitive border region.
In the other picture I'm with former Sikkim Chief Minister NB Bhandari, former Sikkim Lok Sabha MP PM Subba and former Sikkim minister KN Upreti at a function in Gangtok on Article 371F a few years back. Are we mourning the death of our distinct identity within the Union? Upreti once said gradual dilution of Article 371F will lead to its inevitable death. Now that electoral politics is over for the moment will concerned Sikkimese come together and save Sikkim and the Sikkimese people?
Just Out!!
Book: The Lone Warrior: Exiled In My Homeland
Author: Jigme N Kazi
Publisher: Hill Media Publications, Gangtok, Sikkim
Price: Rs. 525/-
AVAILABLE AT:
Observer Building, Nam Nang, Gangtok, Sikkim
Kandoika, New Market, MG Marg, Gangtok, Sikkim
Good Books: Old Market, MG Marg, Gangtok, Sikkim
Jainco: New Metro Point, 31A National Highway, Gangtok, Sikkim
Rachna: Development Area, Gangtok, Sikkiim

Bulk copies available at Observer Building, Nam Nang, Gangtok, Sikkim.

Wednesday, June 25, 2014

GRADUAL DILUTION OF SIKKIM’S DISTINCT IDENTITY
In the first picture I’m with three historic personalities of Sikkim politics: Kazi Lhendup Dorji Khangsarpa (centre), the first Chief Minister of Sikkim (1974-1979), Krishna Chandra Pradhan (on Kazi’s right), and Bhim Bahadur Gurung (on Kazi’s left). The three were signatories to the historic May 8, 1973 Tripartite Agreement. This pact was signed between the Government of India, Chogyal of Sikkim and leaders of three major political parties in Sikkim. Former Gangtok MLA and Mayor Balchand Sarda is on the extreme left in the picture.

While LD Kazi represented the Sikkim National Congress in the historic Agreement, KC Pradhan and BB Gurung belonged to the Sikkim Janata Congress. The Late Netuk Tsering represented the Sikkim National Party.
The Agreement while curtailing the Chogyal’s power gave more political rights to the majority Sikkimese Nepalese. It also brought Sikkim closer to India.
The May 8, 1973 Agreement gradually paved way for Sikkim’s absorption into the Indian Union in April-May 1975. Article 371F of the Constitution of India, which provides special status to Sikkim, is based on the May 8th Agreement. 
Viewed from the historical perspective, the 1890 Convention signed between Great Britain and China and the Indo-Sikkim Treaty of 1950 paved way for the May 8th 1973 Tripartite Agreement. Under the 1890 Convention Sikkim was made a British Protectorate. The Protectorate status continued after India’s Independence under the 1950 Treaty.
After the Indian takeover of Sikkim in 1975 Article 371F of the Constitution defined Sikkim’s status within the Indian Union.
The dilution of Sikkim’s special place within India has been a source of constant political tension in the former kingdom after the ‘merger’ in 1975. If the tension continues it may eventually lead to political uncertainty in this strategic and sensitive border region.
In the other picture I'm with former Sikkim Chief Minister NB Bhandari, former Sikkim Lok Sabha MP PM Subba and former Sikkim minister KN Upreti at a function in Gangtok on Article 371F a few years back.

Monday, June 23, 2014

SIKKIM OBSERVER Page 1 Saturday June 21, 2014
Karmapa saddened by demise of Shamar Rinpoche
“My aspirations are yet to be fulfilled”
Karmapa with Shamar Rinpoche
Dharamshala. June 20: The 17th Gyalwa Karmapa Ogyen Trinley Dorjee, has condoled the demise of the 14th Shamar Rinpoche, Mipham Chokyi Lodro, a senior religious leader of Kagyu school of Tibetan Buddhism.
 “I have had an unshakable faith and respect towards Rinpoche from the time I was young," Karmapa  said in a statement issued on 12 June, 2014.
"I had the good fortune of meeting Rinpoche once, with the hope of benefiting the Buddha dharma in general and the lineage in particular, and with the expectation that I may be able to offer some service towards his Dharma activities," he said, adding: "Unfortunately, my aspirations have not, as yet, been fulfilled," The Tibet Post International reported.
Karmapa  said that Sharmapa Rinpoche's "sudden passing away is a matter of great sadness."
He urged his followers to offer prayers: "As soon as I came to know of this hard to believe news, I instructed Rumtek Monastery, (the main seat of our lineage) and other monasteries to make offerings and perform pujas as grand as possible for 49 days. As Rinpoche had taken rest from the degenerate age of strife into the expanse of peace for a while."
"I live with great hope and strong aspirations that Shamar Rinpoche’s reincarnation will embody the life stories of his predecessors, and that good fortune and harmony within the lineage will arise soon," the statement said.
Shamar Rinpoche passed away in Germany on June 11. He was one of the three remaining Regents of Rumtek monastery in Sikkim.
Why Modi's first foreign visit sends a signal to China
New Delhi, June 20: China has been attempting to gain strategic leverage over India by deepening ties with Bhutan. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has kept this in mind when he visited Bhutan this week.
Modi’s decision to make Bhutan the destination of his first official foreign visit is a further indication that his new government has made revitalising neighbourhood ties a priority, according to Monika Chansoria, a Senior Fellow and Head of the China-study Programme at the Centre for Land Warfare Studies, New Delhi.
Bhutan’s geographical position makes it a key strategic asset, being landlocked between China’s Tibet Autonomous Region to the north and Indian states of Sikkim, West Bengal, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh to the west and south. Though Bhutan and China do not have established official diplomatic ties, they do maintain political and people-to-people contacts, and a degree of economic cooperation.
Indian official circles are aware of Chinese attempts to gain strategic leverage over India by deepening ties with Bhutan, and was kept in mind during the Prime Minster’s visit.
China shares a 470-km border with Bhutan to the north and has held 21 rounds of essentially fruitless boundary talks with China to resolve the boundary dispute. In the boundary-resolution dialogues between Thimphu and Beijing, the Chinese appear particularly focused on the Doklam Plateau (measuring 270 sq. km).
The Doklam Plateau is extremely close to the vital Chumbi Valley area and the Siliguri Corridor, the lifeline that connects India’s Northeast to the rest of the country. By making this plateau a key strategic pivot in the India-Bhutan-China equation, Beijing is working towards expanding its strategic advantage in the Chumbi Valley as well as closing in on access to the Siliguri Corridor, which lies 500 km from the Chumbi Valley.
This is why the recent announcement of Gautam Bambawale as India’s next Ambassador to Bhutan comes as a very interesting development. Bambawale currently serves as Joint Secretary, East Asia, in the Ministry of External Affairs, and was the lead negotiator of the India-China Border Defence Cooperation agreement, signed in October 2013 by Manmohan Singh and Chinese premier Li Keqiang. Bambawale will be adept at assessing the critical issues, especially those pertaining to boundary resolution.
Modi for strengthening of Bharat-Bhutan relations
Thimphu, June 20: Making Bhutan his first foreign destination, Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday vowed to nurture bilateral relations which he described as "B2B – Bharat to Bhutan" as he held talks with the Bhutanese King and the Premier, discussing an entire gamut of ties.
Embarking on a two-day trip here to display "special and unique" status for Bhutan in India's foreign policy, Prime Minister Modi also inaugurated the Supreme Court complex built by India as part of the developmental cooperation. "The primary focus of both the meetings was the extensive development cooperation between the two countries and measures to enhance the economic ties," official sources said, PTI reported.
 Modi described the bilateral relations as "B2B relations – Bharat to Bhutan relations," the sources said on his meeting with Bhutanese King Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuk and Prime Minister Tshering Tobgay.
Modi announced doubling of scholarships being provided to Bhutanese students in India which will now be worth Rs two crore. Prime Minister Modi also promised to assist Bhutan in setting up a digital library which will provide access to Bhutanese youth to two million books and periodicals.
The fact that the Prime Minister chose Bhutan as his first foreign destination assumes significance since China has lately intensified efforts to woo it and establish full- fledged diplomatic ties with Thimphu. Modi, accompanied by External Affairs Sushma Swaraj, National Security Advisor Ajit Doval and Foreign Secretary Sujatha Singh, was accorded a grand welcome as he arrived at the Paro airport and was received by Tobgay and several of his Cabinet colleagues.
The Bhutanese government rolled out the red carpet as Modi was given a ceremonial guard of honour. The Prime Minister drove down from Paro to Thimphu, a distance of about 50 km, traversing through the picturesque mountainous ranges.
 Common people, including children, in colourful attire lined up most of the road between Paro and Thimphu, waving Indian and Bhutanese flags. Big hoardings carrying Modi's photographs also could be seen en route. Modi's meeting with the Bhutanese King lasted for nearly an hour and then he held talks with Tobgay. Modi expressed satisfaction at India being considered as a privileged partner of Bhutan and underlined that his government "would not only nurture these strong bonds but would also strengthen them."
Woman dies due to GREF, govt negligence: SKM

roads in North Sikkim has led to the death of a woman on Monday.
Gangtok, June 20: Negligence of the State Government and GREF on construction and maintenance of roads in North Sikkim has led to the death of a woman on Monday.
In his letter to Chief Secretary R. Ongmu, Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (SKM) MLA from Kabi Longtsok, North Sikkim, Ugen Nedup Bhutia, has alleged that an elderly woman from Namok died on Monday because she could not get timely and emergent medical treatment.
This was mainly due to poor condition of the North Sikkim Highway and ill-equipped and poorly-staffed primary health centre at Phodong.
Despite numerous representations made to the concerned authorities road condition of the tribal-inhabited area of north district continues to suffer.
The MLA has asked for sufficient number of excavators along the highway on a permanent basis.
“It is however not understandable as to why this kind of delay in prompt maintenance or restoration of roads particularly in the North district is witnessed every time that apparently also speaks the volume of a step motherly treatment that is being meted out,” Bhutia said in the letter.
If India becomes communal, Kashmir will not remain with it: Abdullah
“Kashimir is our home, why should we go to Pakistan”


Former Union Minister and Jammu and Kashmir National Conference (NC) candidate Farooq Abdullah addressing an election campaign rally in Budgam (J&K). (PTI Photo)
Srinagar, June 20: Former Union Minister and National Conference President Farooq Abdullah said recently that Kashmir wouldn’t be part of an India that is “communal” and that those who “vote for Modi should jump into the sea”.
“India can’t be communal,” Farooq said addressing a rally in Srinagar’s Khanyar neighbourhood. “If India becomes communal, Kashmir will not remain with India. It will not remain.” The people of Kashmir will not accept communalism at any cost, he said.
Referring to statements by BJP Bihar leader Giriraj Singh and VHP leader Pravin Togadia, Farooq said: “And then they say those who don’t vote for (Narendra) Modi should go to Pakistan. (I say) those who vote for Modi should jump into the sea… Why should we go? This is our home. We are its owners,” PTI reported.
Earlier, NC leader and J&K Chief Minister Omar Abdullah had said that he would prefer going to Pakistan than to stop criticising Modi.
In Delhi, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) hit back at Farooq Abdullah over his remarks, saying India does not need a certificate from him to become secular.
“Neither the country nor Jammu and Kashmir need a certificate from Farooq Abdullah to become secular. The actual matter of worry is the corrupt government run in Jammu and Kashmir by Abdullah and his son (Omar),” BJP leader Ravi Shankar Prasad said.
Sikkim grateful to former CJI on Assembly seat issue
Make Sikkim a happy place: Justice Venkatachaliah
Former Supreme Court of India Chief Justice, Justice MN Venkatachaliah, with Jigme N. Kazi in Bangalore on April 25, 2014.
Bangalore, June 20: Former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India, Justice MN Venkatachaliah, who in 1993 gave a historic verdict upholding Sikkim Legislative Assembly reservation of 12 seats for the Bhutia-Lepchas and 1 for the Sangha, representing Buddhist monasteries in the former Buddhist kingdom of Sikkim, wants the people of Sikkim to be happy.
“Make Sikkim a happy place. People there deserve to be happy,” the former CJI told Jigme N Kazi, author and journalist, who called on him at his residence here recently.
Kazi, who has been made President of Sikkim unit of the All India Patriotic Forum (AIPF), was accompanied by Forum President Maj. Gen (Retd.) MK Paul.
Justice Venkatachaliah is the Patron-in-Chief of the Forum. Other prominent members of the Forum include Gen. (Retd.) SF Rodrigues, Lt. Gen (Retd.) and former Governor of Assam and JK SK Sinha, former Judge of Supreme Court Santosh Hegde and former Chief Secretary of Sikkim KS Rao.
Kazi has also been made a member of the 11-member National Advisory Council of the Forum. Sonam Dorjee, a senior teacher of Tashi Namgyal Academy (TNA), Gangtok, has also been appointed Secretary and Treasurer of the Forum’s Sikkim unit.
While thanking Justice Venkatachaliah for the Supreme Court’s historic verdict in the Assembly seat case, Kazi also presented his books – Inside Sikim: Against the Tide and The Lone Warrior: Exiled In My Homeland – to the former CJI.
Inside Sikkim, while making references to Justice Venkatachaliah’s verdict on the seat case, gives a thorough background on the whole issue.
In his order, Justice Venkatachaliah, while upholding Assembly seat reservation of the indigenous Bhutia-Lepchas and Sangha under Article 371F of the Constitution, observed: “The inequalities in representation in the present case are an inheritance and compulsion from the past. Historical considerations have justified a differential treatment.”
These words made all the difference to the struggle for preservation of Sikkim’s distinct identity within the Union.
Editorial
SPECIAL  STATUS
An Article Of Faith
    Union Minister and National Conference President Farooq Abdullah needs to be applauded for his bold stand by those who defend the ‘special status’ provided by the Constitution to several states, including Jammu & Kashmir, Northeast and Sikkim.  Abdullah’s recent warning that Kashmir will not be a part of India if the Modi-led BJP government pursues its Hindutva agenda and goes ‘communal’. Much the same sentiments will be echoed in the Northeastern states of the country, including Sikkim, if New Delhi is bent on erasing the distinct identity and concessions provided to the peoples of the frontier regions during their ‘merger’ with the Indian Union.
    The BJP manifesto states that the party is committed to abrogating Article 370. If the BJP rakes up the controversial issue to strengthen its hold among the subcontinent’s Hindu populace there is likely to be a major political uncertainty in most border states of the country which feel uncomfortable with the way New Delhi has been handling their affairs. An editorial in Greater Kashmir newspaper recently stated: “The Article (Art 370) has actually served as a bridge to facilitate J&K’s accession with India. Its abrogation would be tantamount to burning this bridge.” JK’s main opposition party, People’s Democratic Party (PDP), has said that Article 370 cannot be abrogated without bringing into question the fundamentals of that relationship. While terming Article 370 as “an article of faith”, the PDP said Article 370 is non-negotiable and irrevocable.
      It may be recalled that the Supreme Court of India during the hearing of a controversial case to abrogate Article 371F (Sikkim) in the Sikkim Legislative Assembly seat reservation issue in early 1984 observed that if Article 371F is abrogated Sikkim will not remain a part of India. It may not be an overstatement to state that if New Delhi continues to dilute the special provisions meant for JK and Northeastern states, including Sikkim, the people of the region may soon lose faith in India and decide not to be a part of it.

"Rise oh fallen fighters, rise and take your stance again!"
                                                                                       BOB MARLEY
                                                                                          Since1986
                                     Sikkim OBSERVER
                                                              The VOICE OF SIKKIM