Sunday, August 26, 2012


SIKKIM OBSERVER   Aug 25, 2012
Renown Sikkimese photographers honoured on World Photography Day
     (L to R) Joseph Lepcha, Kiran Rasaily, Jigme N Kazi and Tenzing C. Tashi at the inaugural function of World    
     Photography Day in Gagtok on Sunday.

Gangtok, Aug 24: The week-long World Photography Day 2012 celebrations in Sikkim, which began here  on Sunday (August 19), is dedicated to two Sikkimese gentlemen, whose pioneering work in the field of photography in Sikkim, has been much appreciated by those who knew them well.
For the old Gangtokians, late Tseten Tashi (popularly known as ‘Rhenock Yap Maila’ or TTT i.e. Tse Ten Tashi)) and his son late Paljor Dorji Tashi, are well-known figures in Sikkim.
Tenzing C. Tashi, daughter of Paljor Tashi (also known as Penjorla) and research assistant at the Namgyal Institute of Tibetology (NIT), Gangtok, who was present during the inaugural function, describes her grandfather, recipient of Pema Dorji (the highest civilian award during the Chogyal era) and former Secretary to the Chogyal of Sikkim, as “a man much ahead of his times.”  Tenzing Tashi, who provided all the photographs of her father and grandfather for the exhibition, says most people remember her father as “a simple, unassuming man who was always approachable, and ever ready to lend a helping hand.”
Organised jointly by Vivid Kala Akademi Sikkim (VIKAS) and Journalist Union of Sikkim (JUS), the photography exhibition, including some rare and unique photographs by late Yap Tseten Tashi and Yap Penjorla, at the old Star Cinema Hall, New Market, MG Marg, will conclude on August 26.
Sikkim Observer editor Jigme N Kazi, chief guest for the inaugural function, said the photographs reflected Sikkim’s people, history and cultural heritage.
Speaking at the inaugural function here on August 19, VIKAS President Kiran Rasaily said the World Photography Day in Sikkim is being organized to “honour their (Yap Tseten Tashi and his son Yap Penjorla) pioneering contributions in the field of photography in Sikkim.” Rasaily, who knew the duo intimately, said more photographs of people, flora and fauna, wildlife and nature will also be exhibited during the celebrations.
JUS General Secretary Joseph Lepcha said, “We are helping and supporting Vivid Kala Akademi, which is celebrating World Photography Day for the second time in Sikkim. We hope local youths will come for the exhibition and see our past history.”
Some of the photographs exhibited are by some local journalists, including Bijoy Gurung, Pappu  Mallick and Prabin Khaling.

SIKKIM People & Places
IN FOND REMEMBRANCE OF OUR YESTERYEARS: TWO OF A KIND
By Tenzing C. Tashi

Her grandfather Yap Tse Ten Tashi, son of Rhenock Athing Rai Sahib Kazi Sonam Dadul, was not only Secretary to the Chogyal of Sikkim but also Sikkim’s first well-known native photographer. Tenzing C. Tashi, writer and research assistant at the Namgyal Institute of Tibetology (NIT), says her father Yap Paljor Dorje Tashi was basically “an IPR man” and pursued his passion for photography with equal zeal and competence as his father.

YAP TSE TEN TASHI
‘Amongst his innumerable specimens, Tse Ten Tashi himself is the rarest of them all’
Rhenock Yap Tse Ten Tashi was the official photographer of the Chogyal of Sikkim and King of Bhutan
Yap Tse Ten Tashi

A feisty man who captured the collective imagination of many, Rhenock Yap Tse Ten Tashi doffed many hats: orchidologist, amateur botanist, photographer, entrepreneur, and much-loved friend and family man.
A scion of the Rhenock Dhakarpa family that traces its roots back to two of Sikkim’s finest native military brains-Changzod Chothup a.k.a. General Satrajeet for his 17 consecutive victories over marauding Gorkha armies, and Deba Tsang Rinzin- TTT, as he liked to call himself, was above all, a Sikkimphile.
He served as Private Secretary to Chogyal Tashi Namgyal, Crown Prince Paljor Namgyal and Chogyal Palden Thondup Namgyal. In 1963, he was conferred one of Sikkim’s highest honours, the Pema Dorji, in recognition of distinguished service rendered to the Sikkim Darbar.
Largely a self-taught man, his perennial thirst for knowledge; all pervasive passion for orchids, rhododendrons and alpine plants; and boundless energy translated into a legendary reputation that spread beyond the borders of his native Sikkim.           
For most travellers, a visit to TTT’s residence in Sikkim was de rigueur, the high point of their visit. There, amidst a profusion of blooms in his roof top orchidarium, his Rhode Island Red poultry farm in the background, Yap Tse Ten Tashi was a suave and effortless host.
He would proffer his guest an orchid, his trademark ‘chang’ and then, as Dean Gaspar said,
‘he talked, with a great personal pride, of Sikkim and the Royal Family, of mountains and flowers and birds and butterflies and people...all, with an imagery that captivated’.
A man much ahead of his times, and with a bewildering plethora of interests that ranged from bodybuilding-it is said he could bend an iron bar against the wall with his chest!- to trying to discover a native cure for cancer, TTT was somewhat of an enigma to most of his contemporaries.
TTT had an intuitive understanding of plants and discovered many new species and mutations. He used to send specimens of his discoveries to Kew Gardens where the scientific community would minutely dissect the flower to check if it was indeed a new species; a genuine find could be named by the finder. On the eve of the coronation of the 12th Denjong Chogyal in 1965, TTT discovered a new orchid, Sikkim’s 601st orchid to be precise, which he promptly named ‘Cymbidium Eburneum var. Denjong Chogyal.’ Among others, he also named another orchid ‘Dendrobium Ashi Kesang Wangchucki’ after the Queen Mother of Bhutan.
The American Rhododendron Society (ARS) contracted him to collect seeds of several rhododendrons and send them to the ARS, which then used them to grow several seedlings. Even today, rhododendrons that trace their origins back to these seeds dot American landscapes.
The triumvirate of Yap Tse Ten Tashi; former Chief Secretary of Sikkim, Mr. K.C.Pradhan and Mr. Britt Smith of the ARS  pioneered conservation efforts in Sikkim, culminating ultimately in the creation of the Khangchendzonga National Park and the Kyangnosola Alpine Plant Sanctuary. The latter is home to Tse Ten Tashi Cave, an ornithologist’s haven.
TTT probably started taking photographs in the wake of the German Schäfer expedition to Tibet via Sikkim in 1938-39. His close friend, Mr.K.C.Pradhan recollects that “TTT’s first camera was a Rolleiflex Twin-lens Reflex 2.8F TLR. 120 roll film with 16 shots. The Camera was brought by Ernst Schafer in 1938 during German Natural History Expedition.
 Rai Saheb Bhim Bahadur Pradhan, then Forest Manager and close to Schafer, was so enamored with the Camera that he struck a bargain and exchanged with seven tiered ancestral ceremonial brass lamp. The lamp must be either at Berlin or Chicago Museums where the Expedition’s treasures were intercepted at high sea by the Allied Forces.  He used it prolifically and TTT being family friend used to borrow frequently. TTT was so hooked to it that the former gave it to TTT around 1944 as by then he had lost interest in photography.”
Thus began TTT’s long tryst with serious photography, which would see him remembered as one of Sikkim’s first well-known native photographers, and also his appointment as the Court Photographer to both the Chogyal of Sikkim as well as the Druk Gyalpo, the King of Bhutan.
Interestingly, in keeping with his impetuous character, TTT did not stick to one camera or one brand very long. He liked to try out several cameras, and would happily lend and borrow cameras. Although he mostly used and owned modest cameras, he had an innate flair and produced excellent results with them.
Some cameras made a lasting impression on TTT, such as the Hasselblad Camera ordered in the early1960s by some Tibetan gentry. TTT delivered this beauty safely to Tibet, but made sure he tried it out first!
He also used the Asahi Pentax Spotmatic briefly. This commanded a cult following among photographers, and TTT was happy to join its legions of admirers.
But above all, Leica was TTT’s favourite. Most of his slides that he used to stock with Magnum Photos in USA were all from Leica. TTT used to regularly send his slides to photo-stocks, and earn a regular side- income from them, as well as from selling fresh eggs to the Palace and the now Raj Bhavan!
As TTT found it taxing to send his slides and photographs all the way to Mumbai to get them developed, he set up Sikkim’s first photographic studio, Tse Ten Tashi & Co, with his own bathroom at home doubling up as its darkroom! TTT also opened a branch of Tse Ten Tashi & Co in Kalimpong near Jetmull Bhojraj’s establishment.
The Gangtok photo studio or the ‘Parkhang’(Tibetan:studio) as it came to be popularly known, made passport photographs including ID for Tibetan refugees, studio portraits and sold photographs taken by TTT. It also sold postcards based on his photographs.
He trained a number of photographers and dark room technicians, including Rinchen Lepcha and Twan Yang. Yap Tse Ten Tashi himself made several movies on Tibet, of which only a few survive today. The fate of a cine-movie that he took of His Holiness the XIVth Dalai Lama’s flight from Tibet and apparently sold to someone abroad remains unknown.
TTT was fully aware that he was recording history through his photographs, commenting that one day, his photographs would be invaluable testimonials of history. At one time, he had an exhaustive collection of photographs taken in Sikkim, Bhutan and Tibet. Sadly, not much remains of his collection today. While a few photographs nestle in family albums, the major bulk of his collection is lost forever. Many of the photographs in the retrospective on display here were sourced from abroad.
A jovial, gregarious and extremely vital personality, Yap Tse Ten Tashi had several friends and admirers. Nari Rustomji, Dewan of Sikkim aptly summarized him as,
‘Amongst his innumerable specimens, Tse Ten himself is the rarest of them all - a truly, truly precious bloom, radiating, through all the seasons, fragrance, beauty, humour, scholarship and- greatest of them all - compassion.’
Perhaps it is only fitting that Yap Tse Ten Tashi chose to name his residence in Gangtok bazaar ‘Light of Sikkim Building’.
YAP PALJOR DORJI TASHI
‘The height of greatness is not how tall you stand, but how much you stoop to shake the smallest hand’
Yap Penjorla not only inherited his father’s love for photography but had the gift of being able to relate to anyone from any strata of society
Yap Paljor Dorji Tashi

The eldest son of Yap Tse Ten Tashi, Yap Penjorla not only inherited his father’s love for photography but also exhibited the same easy charm of his father.  
The Rhenock family having traditionally rendered consummate service to the Darbar, it seemed only natural for a young Penjorla to join the Palace in 1966 as the Aide-de-camp to Chogyal Palden Thondup Namgyal. Conscientious and loyal, he quickly rose to the post of Deputy Secretary to the Chogyal.
As Sikkim made the transition from Himalayan kingdom to 22nd state of India in 1974-75, Penjorla also made the personal transition as Deputy Secretary in the Home Department. In 1975, the Department of Tourism was created and he served as the first Deputy Director. In 1979, the State Government created the Protocol Division of the Home Department; he was chosen to helm it as Joint Secretary. He also served as the first Director of the Information and Public Relations Department. He held several posts in his long innings in the State administration until his voluntary retirement as Secretary to the Government in 1997.
But Penjorla always considered himself, in his own words, ‘An IPR man’. IPR was the Department that he could identify with most, and which most people associated him with. He was happy to be able to continue to explore his passion for photography, and to meld it with his official duties. He was the one who introduced the first aerial photography shots for the annual IPR calendar; strapped into his seat but dangling precariously out of a helicopter, he captured frame after frame of Sikkim’s natural beauty from his dangerous vantage point.
An affable man, Penjorla established a formidable reputation as a man of great integrity and greater humility, earning himself the sobriquet of ‘Buddha Bhagwan.’ He exemplified the idiom, “The height of greatness is not how tall you stand, but how much you stoop to shake the smallest hand.”
His friends, contemporaries and most especially his subordinates from various Departments remember him as a simple, unassuming man who was always approachable, and ever ready to lend a helping hand. He had the gift of being able to relate to anyone from any strata of society, a trait that was to win him many loyal friends who still speak of him with much love and respect.
    A former colleague at IPR, late Mr. Pemba Thondupla, wrote of him: ‘We, in IPR Department, learnt a lot and benefited immensely from his wise counsel. Yap Penjorla himself was so however so modest and unpretentious that he can honestly be termed humility personified. He always passed on the credit of good work to others and took the blame on himself. Generous, sympathetic and courteous, he went out of his way to help his subordinate staff with whom he often merrily shared his snacks and jokes. There was not an iota of vanity in him.’
It is difficult to ascertain when exactly Penjorla started his tryst with photography, but as he was one of the very first subjects of his father’s photography while he was still in diapers, he was exposed to photography at a very early age. He cut his teeth on the other aspects of photography while helping at his father’s Tse Ten Tashi & Co. studio. Photography was such an integral part of his father’s life that it was only a natural corollary that Penjorla should also gravitate towards it.
One of the earliest cameras he inherited from his father was a Mamiya, of Japanese make. A close friend, Mr. Babulal Malu of Panorama, recollects that it was a Sekor Super 23, with 120 mm format.
Later, while dabbling with mid-format cameras, Penjorla enjoyed the developments of the 70s and 80s, which saw major battles between the major Japanese SLR brands: Canon, Nikon, Pentax, Minolta and Olympus. Cameras were no longer heavy, all-metal and manual brutes; the invention of the IC resulted in much sleeker beauties with electronic automation and compact, lightweight bodies.
Originally, like most other photographers, Penjorla was enamoured of Nikon SLRs. This ruled the professional SLR market, with its dual advantages of solid quality and worksmanship. Among other Nikon models, he used a Nikon F1 for a long time, and extolled its virtues.
In the late 1970s, Penjorla was particularly taken in by his Canon AE-1, a 35 mm SLR film camera for use with interchangeable lenses. This historic camera was the first microprocessor-equipped SLR and notched up sales of over one million units, due to a successful marketing strategy. The various manual controls and accessories, combined with the lightweight body and unbeatable price, appealed to Penjorla who went on to own many other Canon cameras.
Like his father, he liked to own and try out a series of modest cameras and zoom lenses. He briefly flirted with other brands like Pentax, Minolta and Olympus but continued to be an A1 and F1 man for the longest time ever, despite owning a more sophisticated Canon EOS Rebel. He was well-conversant with the intricacies of owning and using a SLR, and his conversations were often peppered with terms like ‘aperture/ thyristor/Nikkor zoom/shutter speed’ at a point of time when there were very few aficionados of photography in Sikkim.
With regard to his photography, he was essentially a purist. He mostly liked to work with 35mm Ektachrome transparencies. He preferred the challenge of manual focus, fixing his own lens, and setting the aperture and shutter speed manually for the perfect frame. Although he sometimes enjoyed the relative ease of autofocus, and fixed lens, he held that too much technology killed the real art of photography. He also preferred black and white film, saying that colours detracted from the essence of shape and form.
When the first digital cameras came out, beyond a cursory onceover, he had no real interest in what was being heralded as the new dawn of photography. He was old school; he enjoyed the setting up of a shot, the taking of the shot and yes, the delicious anticipation that marked the wait for a roll of film to be developed and printed.
As a photographer too, Penjorla was more inspired by the simple beauty of things. Mountains were a particular favourite. He would wake up early and spend hours waiting for dawn to break over Mt. Khangchenzonga, and capture the changing silhouettes of the mountain in a series of mostly 36 exposures. Although there was no digital imaging those days, he would carefully overlap his photographs on each other and stick them together to produce the entire Khangchendzonga range. He also loved to shoot portraits, and would often be spotted cajoling someone with a particularly expressive face to pose for his lens.
At first glance, his photographs are deceptively ordinary. A more introspective examination reveals how his lens manages to capture the extraordinary beauty of seemingly very ordinary every day events. His photos transcend the obvious to explore and reveal to the viewer the finer, more subtle nuances of relationships, events and just being.
He was a prolific photographer, and loved to document events and milestones. He built up a huge collection of photographs that encompass mountains, chortens, monasteries, landscapes, flora, fauna, festivals, the Royal Family and always, his people portraits. These are being worked into a currently under-production coffee-table book on Sikkim called ‘Hiatus in the Himalayas’, which is, in a nutshell, one man’s lens, his daughter’s words.
His soul was his window to the world and his lens captured that essential goodness.
(Tenzin C. Tashi, Namgyal Institute of Tibetology (NIT), Gangtok, tinatashi@gmail.com)
Drop Nyati, Todari from forest panel: SIBLAC
By Tseten Tashi Bhutia
Gangtok, Aug 24: You must be aware that the appointment of K.P.Nyati and N.P Todaria in the Forest Advisory Committee has become a subject of national controversy. The Union Ministry of Environment and Forest itself has violated environmental norms while according its clearance to many hydro power projects in Sikkim in the past. 
For instance, the 97 MW Tashiding Hydro Power Project in West Sikkim and 300 MW Panan Hydro Power Project in North Sikkim received the clearance from MoEF without having referred the matter to National Board of Wild Life violating the Supreme Court Order.
Both these HPPs fall within the 10 kms radius from the boundary of Khang-chen-Ddong-nga National Park. As such, the MoEF should have scrapped these projects on the ground that they have violated environmental laws. But the MoEF granted clearance simply to promote the business interest of private companies involved in these projects.
SIBLAC (Sikkim Bhutia-Lepcha Apex Committee) seriously apprehends that appointment of Nyati and Todaria in the Forest Advisory Committee has been made purely to promote the business interest of multi-national companies engaged in hydro-power and mining industry. With this considered opinion, SIBLAC decided to endorse the views of South Asian Network on Dams, River and People (SANDRP) and 49 other NGOs from all across India to cancel the appointment of Nyati and Todaria in the Forest Advisory Committee. (Tseten Tashi Bhutia is Convenor of Sikkim Bhutia-Lepcha Apex Committee – SIBLAC)
Chief Secy visits North Sikkim, assures people on reconstruction work
Sikkim Chief Secretary Karma Gyatso

Mangan, August 24: Chief Secretary Karma Gyatso said till the date the State Government has received only Rs. 200 crore out of the Rs. 1,000 crore promised by the Central Government as earthquake relief fund.
Gyatso, who is on a two-day tour of North Sikkim, assured that Chungthang would be become a model town and a gateway to North Sikkim. He assured the people that the government would do its best to restore assets damaged during last year’s devastating earthquake.
Already Rs 2 crore has been sanctioned for reconstruction of Chungthang monastery, Secretary, Ecclesiastical Department, said. Gyatso, who patiently listened to problems and grievances of the people during a public meeting here, was accompanied by several secretaries and officials during his tour.
The Chief Secretary urged the Border Roads Organisation (BRO) to extend “full support” toward restoration work, an IPR release said.
The Chief Secretary along with the Chief Engineer BRO also visited Khedoom where landslides have totally damaged the road connecting Chungthang with Lachung.
REC to give additional Rs 995-cr loan for Teesta III hydro project
New Delhi, Aug 24: Rural Electrification Corporation (REC) will extend an additional loan of Rs 995 crore to the 1,200-MW Teesta III hydro project in Sikkim whose overall cost has escalated to more than Rs 8,500 crore.
With the additional amount, State-run REC's total lending to the project would be Rs 3,095 crore, sources said.
Teesta III project has seen substantial cost overruns due to delays on account of natural calamities as well as legal hurdles, PTI reported.
Sources said the cost overrun is about Rs 2,700 crore. The additional term loan of Rs 995 crore would include Rs 851crore senior debt. Originally, REC was to lend Rs 2,100 crore for the project, they added.
The fresh amount has been sanctioned since the project cost has jumped to Rs 8,581 crore from Rs 5,700 crore estimated earlier.
Earlier this week, REC communicated to project developer Teesta Urja about its decision to sanction the additional loan, sources said.
As per the original schedule, the project was to come up in September 2012. Now, it is anticipated to be fully operational by December next year. About 70 per cent of work has been completed.
The run of the river project was awarded by the Sikkim government to Teesta Urja Ltd on BOOT (build-own-operate- transfer) basis.
An earthquake last year and differences between Teesta Urja Ltd and Sikkim government have also led to delays in implementation of Teesta III.
Last month, power trading solutions provider PTC India, that holds 11 per cent stake, had said the project is expected to be commissioned in December 2013.
Singapore-based Asian Genco Pte holds 50.1 per cent stake in Teesta III while Sikkim government and Athena Projects has 26 per cent and 11 per cent shareholding, respectively.
The plant, which would supply power to Sikkim and Haryana, among others, would have six units of 200 MW each.
Editorial
JUDICIAL ACCOUNTABILITY
People Are Supreme In Democracy

Mamata Banerjee ought to be applauded for her recent comments on corruption in the judiciary. In response to Calcutta High Court’s admission of a contempt of court petition against Mamata for her remarks on the judiciary the West Bengal Chief Minister minced no words when she said:  “My speech in the Assembly is recorded; you can take a copy of that. I have talked about electoral reforms, judicial reforms and administrative reforms. If talking about our country's drawbacks is a crime, I am ready to commit it a thousand times.” A similar petition was also filed in the Supreme Court seeking contempt action against Mamata for her remarks that judgments are delivered for money.

The petitioner has alleged that Mamata’s comments “tends to lower the integrity, reputation and authority” of the judicial system in the country and would undermine people’s confidence in the judiciary. It must me noted that the West Bengal Chief Minister did not wage an all-out war against the judiciary only. She is absolutely right when she defended her stand:  “Each profession has good and bad people. I have talked about the lack of values in various fields including the judiciary, politics and media.” Mamata will surely give a befitting reply to those who fail to see things in its proper perspective. Though there are many in the judiciary whose reputation is above reproach the public is widely aware of the lack of people’s faith in the judiciary as a whole. If speaking the truth, even on the judiciary, can be construed as contempt of the court who will take action those who are guilty of contempt of justice?

ALIEN ISSUE

Take Wake-Up Call Seriously

In the current crisis in Assam the electronic media seems to be helping the establishment in diverting the attention of the people from the real problems and issues faced by the people in the Northeast, including Sikkim. Day after day there are television debates on “social media”, “rumours” on who is behind all the violence and mass exodus from southern parts of the country to the Northeast. As usual the government sees a foreign hand and in this case the blame is on Pakistan. We must be reminded that vested interests, including foreign powers, will surely fish in troubled waters. But the essential thing is to get to the bottom of the matter and look into the real causes of what is happening in the Northeast.

The BJP has categorically stated that the real issue in the Northeast is a fight between Indians and foreigners. Opposition AGP President and former chief minister Prafulla Kumar Mahanta, too, has rightly pointed out: "Non-implementation of the Assam Accord and failure to detect and deport the illegal immigrants are the main reasons for the present crisis. The fate of Assam's indigenous people is being sacrificed for political expediency."

It is a fact that despite local opposition lakhs of illegal immigrants in Assam have been provided valid government documents to prove their nationality as Indian citizens by “powerful patrons”. In Sikkim, too, fake “Sikkim Subjects Certificates” are provided to non-bonafide Sikkimese and this issue is gradually becoming a major political agenda for the Opposition.  Putting the balm over the present turmoil to ease mass exodus to the Northeast should only be a temporary measure to stem the crisis. The country has suddenly realized how race and religion in India’s vulnerable Northeast can become a cocktail for a major political movement that would dangerously endanger the country’s security interest and territorial integrity in the strategic and sensitive region. If the present wake-up call is buried under the rubbles of temporary peace and quite then we are heading towards a greater political catastrophe in the not too distant future.

No comments:

Post a Comment