SIKKIM OBSERVER Saturday   June 1-7, 
2013    
Danny back on silver screen, to star in Boss, Mental
Mumbai, May 31:
Danny Denzongpa sure knows how to live life at his own pace. When not shooting,
and that's for a good part of the year, the actor spends his days at his Sikkim
farmhouse, completely switched off from the rest of the world. But when thrown
into the hustle and bustle of Bollywood, he also tends to make the right moves.
The latest is he has picked
two interesting films - one with Akshay Kumar and the other with Salman Khan.
The 65-year-old actor will be seen in an action avatar in Boss and also in Mental
respectively, Mumbai Mirror reported.
A source revealed: "Danny
will be doing handto-hand combat in Akshay-starrer Boss. Despite his age, his reflexes are like that of a young man.
As for Mental, he will start shooting
the film soon."
According to the source,
"Danny has a fabulous equation with the A-listers in the industry. But he
has always opted for roles that suit his character. He has been friends with
Akshay and Salman for a long time. They felt he was the best choice for the
roles in these films."
Dzongu’s gift for Golay’s SKM: anti-dam activist Dawa
Lepcha
Dawa Lepcha during anti-dam hunger strike
in Gangtok (right)
Gangtok, May 31:
PS Golay’s biggest catch for his recently-formed political outfit Sikkim
Krantikari Morcha (SKM) is undoubtedly the renown social activist Dawa Lepcha
who with his friends unsuccessfully fought against mega hydel projects in his
native district of North Sikkim.
Golay’s recent trip to North
Sikkim, including the Lepcha-dominated region of Dzongu, was successful in a
sense that the party managed to convince the people that it was against mega
hydel projects in the State.
Golay, infact, informed the
people that one of the main reasons for going against the ruling government was
on hydel projects. He was against it, he said. This message went down well with
the people.
“The Lepchas are with Dawa and
Golay did the right thing by choosing him,” a Lepcha leader said.
When he left the Affected
Citizens of Teesta (ACT), the organization which headed the anti-dam movement
in the State, in February this year to join the SKM, Dawa told his colleagues
in the ACT that he would pursue the issue in politics. His friends in the ACT
have realized how unresponsive and dubious the Chamling Government is on the
issue.
“We have sat on hunger strikes,
begged and used other options for a long time (on scrapping hydel power projects
proposed in Dzongu) but nothing happen. I believe that social activism has not
yielded much and time has come for us to approach a political solution for our
demands”, said Dawa when he joined the SKM on February 4 this year.
Without Bhandari Congress is nothing in
Sikkim
Gangtok, May 31:
The Congress party high command’s reported decision to take Sikkim seriously
will not convince anyone in Sikkim. If fact, by removing former chief minister
NB Bhandari from SPCC presidentship on the eve of the Assembly elections the
Congress party has proved that it is not serious in building up the party and
forming the government in the State.
During a meeting of the SPCC held
here this week, AICC Secretary K. Jayakumar said the party would take the State
seriously. He said every month a union minister would come to the State to
campaign for the ensuing Assembly polls.
Ever since Sikkim’s takeover the
Congress party, which was chiefly responsible for Sikkim’s ‘merger’ with India,
has not been able to win elections to form the government. 
It was able to form the
government in Sikkim on two occasions: in 1981 and 1994. The Congress party was
able to form the government under Bhandari in 1981 when Bhandari’s party –
Sikkim Janata Parishad – merged with the Congress in July 1981. After
Bhandari’s Sikkim Sangram Parishad – formed on May 24, 1984 – dissidents
toppled his government in May 1994 the Congress party was able to form the
government for a brief while under Sanchaman Limboo in 1994.
Try as it may the Congress party
– without Bhandari – never got more than 4% of the vote share. Under Bhandari,
the Congress party’s vote-bank rose to around 30% in the Assembly elections in
2004 and 2009.
So, what is the justification
for Bhandari’s removal at this juncture? During the SSP meeting here on May 24,
Bhandari said he would reduce the Congress to a ‘zero’ in Sikkim. He does not
have to do anything on this now; the party high command did the job.
Central or Congress leaders from
Delhi mean nothing to the people of Sikkim as far as electioning is concerned.
They can bring money, not votes. Some of them even take money from Sikkim.
Political observers are of the
opinion that Congress did a big favour to Pawan Chamling by removing Bhandari
as SPPC chief. “Now opposition votes remain divided. This goes in Chamling’s
favour,” one observer said. His views may reflect public opinion in days to
come. 
Union tribal minister does not know
Limboos, Tamangs are STs in Sikkim
    (L to R) Chief Minister Pawan Chamling,
Union Tribal Affairs Minister KC Deo, and Lok Sabha MP PD Rai during the    
    Sakewa
celebrations at Saramsara, East Sikkim, on Monday.
Gangtok, May 31:
Those who want Assembly seat reservation for the Limbus and Tamangs in the
State should note that the Union Minister for Tribal Affairs KC Deo does not
even know that the two communities have been enlisted in the ST list in the
State.
During the annual Sakewa
celebrations at Saramsara Garden near here on Sunday, Deo said he would do his
utmost to ensure that Limbus and Tamangs are declared STs in the State. Chief
Minister Pawan Chamling and Sikkim’s lone Lok Sabha MP PD Rai were present on
the dais when Deo made the statement.
Justifiably, the Sikkim
Limboo-Tamang Tribal Forum has lambasted the Chamling Government for Deo’s
lapses. Forum Chairman Birbal Limboo in a press statement said it was
unfortunate that the Union Minister does not even know that the two communities
were declared tribals way back in 2003.
Even after 10 years the two
communities have not got seats reserved in the Assembly, the Forum said and
blamed the Chamling Government for its failure to take the matter to the
Centre.
POWER CORRUPTS
Quit Gracefully, Mr.
Srinivasan
The conspiracy of silence
within the BCCI was broken when board heavyweight and Union Power Minister Jyotiraditya
Scindia publicly said President N Srinivasan should quit.
Realising that there is a
conflict of interest as Srinivasan’s own family member is involved in an
ongoing investigation, it's in the fitness of things, from a point of view of
propriety, that he should step aside until this matter reaches a conclusive end
in terms of an inquiry, Scindia rightly said, “We are responsible for the
actions of our family members." 
Since then many, including
eminent citizens, have urged the BCCI chief to tender his resignation.  However, the BCCI boss refuses to budge. His flagrant
defiance of public opinion may finally lead to an ignoble exit.  A faction within the Board is planning to
initiate suspension proceedings against him if he refuses to step down in the
aftermath of the Indian Premier League spot-fixing scandal that has thrown
cricket in the country into disarray.  It
is in the best interest of the game that Srinivasan quits gracefully before he
is thrown out.
The Mystery of Sikkim’s  Teesta Hydel Project 
Private developers, who have got
projects through joint venture routes, are enriching themselves at the cost of
the people. Indeed, who owns the lucrative hydropower projects in Sikkim?
    The
Affected Citizens of Teesta (ACT) went on an indefinite hunger strike against
hydropower projects on the sacred 
    Teesta River in Sikkim on June 22, 2007 at BL
(Bhutia-Lepcha) House premises, Gangtok. The campaign – supported by 
    monks,
students, NGOs and the Sikkimese people – in the spirit of Gandhian Satyagraha
was withdrawn after more than   
    two years, on September 27, 2009. 
A lot of money is being
pumped into companies developing hydropower projects in Sikkim ever since the
Central Government allowed 100 per cent FDI in the power sector through the
direct route. Ironically, an in-depth analysis of these investments show that
the finances are being pumped in from tax haven countries like Singapore,
Mauritius, and so on by companies registered in these countries by venture
capitalists and hedge funds.
The best case study in this
connection is TeestaUrja Limited (TUL), an SPV (Special Purpose Vehicle) set up
by Athena Projects Pvt Ltd for developing the 1200MW Teesta Stage III HEP near
Chungthang in North Sikkim. The Singapore-based Asian GencoPvt Ltd is owned by
TV Vijaykumar, an erstwhile close aide of the late YSR Reddy (former chief
minister of Andhra Pradesh), the late CV Balayogi (former Speaker, LokSabha,
also from Andhra), Jagan Mohan Reddy (YSR's son, now in jail) and KVP
RamachandraRao (close associate of the Reddys), and is currently the owner of
the 1200MW Teesta Stage III being developed by TUL. It holds close to 50 per
cent equity in the project.
    Teesta III Hydropower project, Chungthang, North Sikkim:
This 1200 MW project is being executed by M/s Teesta Urja 
    Limited, also an
Athena Group company.
A clique of investors, led by
Morgan Stanley Infrastructure Partners, bought close to 49 per cent stake in
power generation and engineering services firm Asian Genco for $425 million in
2010, the biggest private equity (PE) transaction in India in the power sector.
The deal is also the first one of over $300 million since 2008. The last PE
deal of this size was when Providence Equity Partners invested $428 million in
Aditya Birla Telecom in 2008.
The group of investors in
Asian Genco includes Everstone Capital, General Atlantic, Goldman Sachs
Investment Management and Norwest Venture Partners, among others. Asian Genco,
to which the former power secretary of Delhi, RV Shahi, is learnt to be a
consultant, had earlier raised funds from other investors like power trading
firm PTC and its finance offshoot, PTC Financial Services, besides global
investors such as Tiger Global Management.
This has been a trend for
many of the Independent Power Producers (IPPs) developing projects in Sikkim,
wherein, as per the clauses in their Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the
state government, land is mortgaged in lieu of huge project finances picked up
by the developers with the state government standing as a guarantor (as per the
MoU, the government of Sikkim owns either 26 per cent or 11 per cent equities
in these projects).
The best example is TUL,
which, in 2008, took Rs 4,500 crore as loan from REC and a consortium of seven
nationalised banks and parked the funds in Asian Genco. Lanco projects did the
same with investments in coal mines in South Africa, Griffin mines in Australia
and a coal mine and a thermal power plant in Chhattisgarh, all with the help of
finances from land mortgaged in Sikkim.
Coastal Projects Sikkim has
sold shares at a premium to Baring Asia Equity Group at 65 times the face
value; such value addition is fully and only attributable to their ownership of
the concerned hydropower project they are executing in Sikkim. Had this
organisation executed the required Shareholder Agreement (Share Subscription
Agreement) and allotted the Sikkim government 26 per cent equity within 180
days of the agreement, the state government, as minority shareholder, would
have got first preference to dilute and could have decided to off-load parts of
its equity at 65 times the face value. In this way, the state government is
denied its dues and gains which the private developers tactfully and wrongfully
embezzled (Source: Coastal Annual Report).
Analysis of these investments
show that the finances are being pumped in from tax haven countries like Singapore,
Mauritius, and so on by companies registered in these countries by venture
capitalists and hedge funds
Private developers who have
got projects through joint venture (JV) routes, are enriching themselves at the
cost of the state and its people. This was the case in Jal Power Corporation
Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of Coastal Projects Private Limited,
Hyderabad. In the 75:25 debt equity ratios of Coastal Projects in the JV, the
Sikkim government has, at the rate of 26 per cent equity, Rs 50.40 crore.
Likewise, the
Luxembourg-based Greenko Energy Ventures Private Limited controls the shares in
the 96MW Dikchu Hydropower Project, a JV between the Sikkim government and
Sneha Kinetic Power Projects Private Limited (an SPV). The Sikkim government is
entitled to 26 per cent equity in it. Greenko has raised $46.3 million in
allotting its preference shares (Source: Greenko Annual Report).
In the remand report of Jagan
Reddy, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has clearly stated that in his
Sandur Power Company Limited (SPCL), the Lanco group has purchased considerable
shares. Lanco is doing the Teesta Stage VI project in Sikkim.
The Singapore-based River
Valley Hydro Venture owns 75 per cent stake in Secunderabad-based AmritJal
Ventures (Source: TheEconomic Times), worth Rs 300 crore. AmritJal has floated
three SPVs, Gati Infrastructure, Gati Infrastructure Bhasmey and Gati
Infrastructure SadaMangder for three projects in Sikkim. According to an
Economic Times report (February19, 2009), the owners of AmritJal Ventures were
not clearly known.
In TUL, Mauritius-based
Varuna Investments Private Limited holds 100 per cent preference shares of
Singapore-based Asian Genco, owned by TV Vijay Kumar. Asian Genco owns 50.9 per
cent equity of TUL, leaving 49.1 per cent equity for the consortium partners of
Athena Power Projects Limited (APPL) and the Sikkim government which is
supposed to hold 26 per cent equity in the JV.
The MOU signed by the Sikkim
government with every IPP, modelled on the standard agreement it signed with
TUL, stipulates on the issue of equity subscription that, "The company
shall not change the constitution of the company's board without prior
permission from the government." If there is a violation of this clause,
the Government of Sikkim (GoS) can unilaterally terminate the agreement. In
reality, the GoS under Chief Minister PawanChamling chose not to disturb the
status quo, despite gross illegality, violation of the MoU, quid pro quo
benefits enjoyed by the troika of politicians, bureaucrats and businessmen, not
to mention huge losses to the state exchequer.
In reply to an RTI
application, the private hydropower developers said that, as a private limited
company, they are outside the purview of the RTI Act, 2005, and it is not
applicable to them; signatories to the MoU have no rights under the
implementation agreement with the company.
From this response it becomes
clear that none of the companies that have been awarded projects by the GoS
consider themselves to be in a joint venture and thus are not answerable. To
top it all, in many cases, the original owners are untraceable or have become
minority shareholders, having sold or transferred their equity to third parties
who have nothing to do with the MoU or the GoS. Indeed, this raises serious
legal issues. (Hard News and HT
Syndication)
There can be no peace in Sikkim unless healthy
survival is ensured
Despite aggressive changes Sikkim
cannot afford to abandon its past
By SUNANDA K. DATTA-DAY
The seminar on "Tibet's
Relation with the Himalayas" that the Foundation for Non-Violent
Alternatives (FNVA) organised in Gangtok last week recalled Jigdal Densapa who
died recently. Descended from Sikkim's ancient Lepcha chiefs and a hereditary
Kazi of Barmiok, Densapa was secretary to the last Chogyal of Sikkim. Sir
Patrick Shaw, a former Australian high commissioner to India, called him
"the only modern man in Sikkim".
That's what I remembered as
learned seminar papers by Sangeeta Thapliyal of the Jawaharlal Nehru
University, the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses' Col P K Gautam or
Nani Bath of Itanagar's Rajiv Gandhi University focussed on threats to national
identity in Nepal, Ladakh and Arunachal Pradesh. With modernity run riot in
Sikkim, I didn't see a single man in the ankle-length robe called baku or kho,
which is the Sikkimese male's traditional attire. Densapa wore it with dignity.
The empty desolation of the
Chogyal's palace is as indicative of the new Sikkim as bustling crowds in the
wide walkway of Mahatma Gandhi Marg. Its crowded shops and cafes cater mainly to
budget tourists whose colloquial Bengali rises stridently above the hubbub. But
here and there, pleasant sanctuaries like Baker's Cafe and the just-opened
Coffee Shop, offer a touch of more sophisticated leisure. Where smelly,
run-down Dewan's in the bazaar was once the only hostelry, hotels now sprout
every few yards, ranging from the ostentatious Mayfair and elegant Denzong
Residency to hole-in-the-wall hovels. Two boast casinos where locals squander
their new-found wealth on the turn of the wheel.
Rajiv Gandhi's calculation
that only 15 per cent of development funds reach the target means that 600,000
Sikkimese are making money hand over fist. In their past innocence, my
Sikkimese friends didn't think of exploiting the absence of excise duty under
the Chogyal. But the shrewd Indian businessmen who flooded Gangtok after the
protected kingdom became India's 22nd state quickly grasped they needed only an
address in Sikkim, a front man and a dummy company to make a killing from
duty-free goods. Soon, greed overcame prudence. Factories elsewhere in India
began rolling out manufactures stamped "Made in Sikkim". The
exchequer may have lost Rs 3,50 crore on evaded tobacco duty alone.
Despite aggressive changes,
however, Sikkim cannot afford to abandon its past. The 300,000 registered
"Sikkim subjects" (meaning they or their ancestors were bona fide
residents of the kingdom) pay no income tax. About 225,000 of them are ethnic
Nepalese. Another 35,000 Nepalese probably have fake certificates. Sikkim's Tibeto-Buddhist
ethic has been watered down, and some indigenes complain of existing on
sufferance. Kazi Lendhup Dorji, the first chief minister whom many Sikkimese
regard as the "country-seller" even while they formally honour his
memory, once chided me for not speaking Nepalese. "It's the language of
the people," he said.
The monarchy would never have
been overthrown and the kingdom merged without Nepalese cooperation. Since they
accused the Chogyal and his Bhutiya-Lepcha courtiers of trampling on their
Hindu Nepalese identity, you would expect them to make common cause now with
West Bengal's militant Nepalese, especially as Darjeeling district once
belonged to Sikkim. Gangtok's fairy-tale Assembly even recently passed a
resolution supporting Gorkhaland. But do they want to join it? Certainly not.
As Kazi's Hindu ethnic Nepalese successor Nar Bahadur Bhandari put it, Sikkim
had merged but would not be submerged.
Since they are no longer
fighting a durbar that derived its symbols and rituals from Manchu China, the
Nepalese who constitute 75 per cent of Sikkim's population don't need to
reinvent themselves as Gorkha. They are proudly Sikkimese, masters in their own
home. Merger would erode an identity that synthesises the legacy of six
centuries of Tibet's cultural influence. Sikkim can be put in India, but Tibet
can't be taken out of Sikkim. Merger would also cost the Sikkimese their
protected jobs and special privileges.
Uttam Lal, a young idealist
who teaches geography and natural resources management at Sikkim University,
spoke passionately of the threat that both man and beast face on Sikkim's
border with Tibet. He meant mines, barbed wire fencing and other defensive
measures. The menace of modernity is no less serious. It is as much in need of
the attention of organisations like the FNVA, which calls itself an
"institute for developing peace studies". There can be no peace
unless healthy survival is ensured. (Business
Standard)
Sikkim Scouts will be part of 11th Gorkha
Rifles
Lucknow, May 31: Friday was indeed a historical day for the Indian Army, the Gorkha
Brigade, 11 Gorkha Rifles & the state of Sikkim, as Vice Chief of Army
Staff (VCOAS) Lieutenant General SK Singh unveiled the flag of Sikkim Scouts.
This new battalion will form part of 11 Gorkha Rifles and will be raised at 11
GRRC, Lucknow.
On this historic moment, the VCOAS,
who is also the 'President of the Gorkha Brigade' unveiled the flag and handed
it over to Colonel Samar Singh Pundir, first commanding officer of the
battalion. The battalion will be permanently located in the high altitude and
rugged terrain of Sikkim, The Times of
India reported.
 This battalion is raised on the concept of
'Sons of Soils' to guard the nation's frontiers. Based on this concept, the
Indian Army already has Ladakh Scouts, Dogra Scouts, Garhwal Scouts, Kumaon
Scouts & the Arunachal Scouts.
The Singh exhorted all
present to work hard and lay a solid foundation. He said that other troops will
stay for 2-3 years in these altitudes and then withdraw, but the Scouts will be
permanently there. 
He also said that the men
have been selected since they are locals, they understand the language and are
fully acclimatised. He remarked that a new beginning has been made and the
Sikkim Scouts must live up to the reputation of the fabled Scouts of Indian
Army.
Bhutia Kerab Yargay Tshogpa: how and why it was formed
By Karma  Lhendup 
Kaleon (left)
            This  is  in 
response  to  the 
report  on  the 
proposed  election  of 
the  governing  body 
of  the  Bhutia 
Kerab  Yargay  Tshogpa (BKYT)  which appeared in  the 
May 10, 2013  issue  of  Sikkim 
Now.  This  came 
as  a  big 
surprise  to  this 
Gembo  as  he 
is  one  of 
the  founder- members  of 
this  organization.  The executive body was never  elected 
since  its  inception. 
As  a  Gembo 
I  must  share the 
story  of  this 
organization with  my  youngsters for  their 
information  and  further 
necessary  action. It is a story of  deception, 
intrigue  and  back- stabbing.
The  BKYT 
was  founded  in 
around 1982  when  this 
Gembo  was  a  restless  young 
man  with  sky-rocketing 
vision  and  enthusiasm. 
He was  much  commented 
upon  for  this 
reason by  his  adversaries. 
Some  said  he 
lived  in  a 
world  of  his 
own  dream  while others 
said  he  did 
things  without  any 
finishing  and  some 
said  he  misguided 
people.  The  story 
of  BKYT  was 
about all  these.  
The  concept of 
the  language  called 
Bhutia was  never  accepted 
by  people  that 
mattered.  Late Lachen  Gomchhen 
was  dead  opposed 
to  it.  For 
that  matter  it 
never  received the  blessings 
of  the  chho-keong-srung-mas  yul-lha 
shib-dag  of  the 
land.  
The  BKYT was 
formed  primarily  to 
develop  and  promote the 
Bhutia language among the 
Lomenlas  in  the 
first  instance.  It 
was  intended  to 
hold  workshops  and 
training  programmes  for 
teaching  the  language 
to  the  language 
teachers  first.  The 
first  meeting  of 
the  organization  was  called  in 
the  White  Hall 
premise  in  open air 
beside  the  resting 
house  called Hawa-ghar   The 
meeting  itself  was 
a  kind  of 
training  programme  for 
the  Lomenlas  on  how  to 
conduct a  meeting,  record 
the  minutes  of 
the  meeting  and adopt 
resolutions.  If  the 
Minute  Book  is 
still  available, you  will 
see  how  many 
people  attended  that 
fateful  meeting.   In 
order  to  give 
the  language  a 
semblance  of   literary 
identity  and  entity, 
this  Gembo  published 
a  monthly  journal 
under  the  title 
of  ‘De-log’  which 
means  resurrection.  This 
magazine  served  as 
the  backbone  of 
the  language   and 
the  show  piece of 
literary  work  in 
the  language.  
There  was 
a  text  book 
writer appointed  for  writing 
books  in  that 
language. He  simply  did 
not  know  how 
to  go  about it. 
Writing a book   by  a 
person  who  never wrote  
was  the  beginning. He 
was  a  monk 
wedded  deeply  to 
the  principle  of 
the  Dhamma  which 
forbids  the  identification  of 
self.   He  never 
wrote  books  in 
his  own  name. 
The  name  of 
this  Gembo  too 
featured  in  the 
books  he  wrote 
for  some  time. 
I  did  not 
like  that  and 
he  was  offended 
and  was  repenting 
later.   I  knew 
beforehand  what  was 
going  to  happen. 
They  happened  to 
him.  He  remained 
unsung.   The  said 
writer should  remember  how 
this  Gembo  initiated 
him into  the  world 
of  creative  writing 
with  his  rudimentary 
knowledge  of  Bhutia.  
This  Gembo  had 
a  fascination  for 
reducing  the  Sikkimese 
language  in  written 
form  from  early 
days.  He  tried 
this in  mixed  Devnagiri 
and  Bhutia  font  
and  published  a 
book  which  later 
became  the  reference 
book  for  the 
writer.
            As  far 
as  the  BKYT 
was  concerned this   Gembo 
had  provided  everything 
ready  -made.  The  logo  was 
designed with  a motto
derived  from  Dhammapadda. 
Letter  pads  were 
printed  enough for  several 
years  as  the 
people  mattered  inspired 
least  confidence in  the 
Gembo.  The  Lomenlas 
were  told  that 
the  BKYT  shall 
be  an  exclusively 
Lomenla  forum where  their 
problems  regarding  the 
language  would  be 
discussed and  to continue  the 
work  as  shown. 
By  Lomenla  I 
mean  a  language 
teacher.  In  those 
days  people  formed 
a  society  and 
went  around  with  khada 
in  hand  in 
search  of  a 
Gembo  to  be 
its  president.  Thereafter, the  society 
flopped  because  the 
hired  president neither  knew 
about  the  purpose 
of  the  society 
nor  was  he 
in  need  of 
one. 
            The  BKYT 
met  with  the 
same  fate  and  
vanished. It  fell  in  the
hands  of 
vested  interests  group 
who hijacked  it  for 
other  purposes.  The 
message  of BKYT  never reached the  Lomenlas 
as  it  never worked 
for  the  objectives 
it  was  created 
for.  The ‘De-log’,  too, 
died. Private  schools  never 
accepted  the neo- Bhutia.  As 
a  result  today 
70 %  of  the 
Lomenlas  knew  neither 
the  Bhutia  nor 
the  Sikkimese  and 
the  number  of 
admission  in  the 
language  dropped  year 
by  year.  The 
poor  Lomenlas  are 
being  withdrawn  from  schools.  A 
year  ago  this 
Gembo  met  one 
heart  broken  Lomenla. 
He  said  the 
Bhutia  as  such 
would  be  extinct 
by   2050  at 
the  present  rate 
of  degeneration.   The 
grave  prediction  of  the  Lomenla  
least  surprised this  Gembo. 
A  work 
done  on  wrong 
premise  is  always 
fallacious.  The  idea 
of  Bhutia  language was 
a  fallacy  and 
extinction  was  natural.  
The  Bhutia  language 
was  created  with 
malicious intention  by  suppressing 
the  Notification  of 
1958.  It  was 
to  give  legitimacy  
to  the  diluted 
definition  of  Bhutia.   
Where  does the  BKYT  
stands  today may  be  
summed  up  from 
a  press  release it 
issued  a  few 
years  back.  It 
came  out  in 
a  local  paper. 
It  expressed  sympathy 
with the  cause  of 
Goukhaland.   It  seems 
it  is  now 
functioning  more  as a 
Bracket  Bhutia  cell of 
certain  political  outfit 
than as a social  body.  Any 
simple  minded  person 
would  think  that 
the  proposed  election 
of  the  BKYT 
is  intended  to 
unify  the  Lomenlas 
for  the  coming 
event ?    Bhutia  is  a
universal  language.  It  cannot  belong 
to  a  community
This  Gembo 
regretted  much that  he  did  not know about  the 
existence  of  the 
Language  Notification  of 
1958   and  the 
Manual  of  Denjong  
Ke  by  Graham 
Sandberg  when  he  was  trying 
to  develop a  methodology 
for  writing  Sikkimese. 
Looking  back  on 
the  hindsight we  see 
how  prophetic  was  
Lachen  Gomchen. His  wisdom 
stands honoured.. 
Therefore, in  homage 
to  the  great 
Lama  this  Gembo 
recommended  teaching  of 
Bhutia  in  Sambhota 
way  and  Sikkimese 
in  Graham  Sandberg 
way.  The  teaching 
of  Bhutia  should 
go  back  to 
Laptras  in  the 
Gumpas and  Sikkimese  be 
introduced in  schools  with 
teachers  from general  education 
background. With  this  in 
view  this  Gembo 
wrote  to  the 
Sangha  MLA  in 
2010  about  the 
idea  of  a 
Laptra  Education  Board 
in  the  format 
of  Muslim  Madrasa Board 
of  Education.   
The  Madrasa 
Board  of  education 
was  conceived  to 
make  the  students 
employable  and  earn 
a  livelihood.  The 
respected  MLA  did 
not  respond  to this 
Gembo.  I do  not know 
whose  interest  he  is  representing. 
He  is  a 
family  man  and 
is  seen  wearing 
the  dress  of a 
Gelong  shamelessly.   If 
the  above  said 
Lomenla,  the  prophet 
of  doom,  know 
all  these  he 
would  definitely  advance 
the  date  of 
extinction  of  the 
Bhutia  to  2020.  (Karma  Lhendup 
Kaleon is a Founder -Member of Bhutia 
Keyrab  Yargay  Tshogpa (BKYT)

.jpg)

.jpg)



No comments:
Post a Comment